The EU is trying to become a welfare superstate
But its powers to deliver on its “social pillar” are limited
EUROPE IS TO the welfare state what Canada is to ice hockey: the birthplace and the summit of the art. The European Union boasts a “unique social market economy” that “protects us against the great risks of life”, Ursula von der Leyen, president of the European Commission, told a summit of EU leaders on May 7th. They had met in Porto, Portugal’s second city, to approve a plan for turning the union into a bulwark of social protection, with targets for raising employment, improving job training and reducing poverty, as well as looser goals such as fighting gender inequality and regulating the gig economy.
Yet Europe’s welfare states are administered by national governments, not by the EU. The European Commission’s powerful regulatory authority rarely extends to social policy. As for EU spending, even with a new €750bn ($910bn) covid-19 recovery fund added to its regular €1.1tn seven-year budget, it amounts to less than 2% of the bloc’s GDP over the period. That pales in comparison to members’ social spending alone, which runs from 13% of GDP (Ireland) to 31% (France). Pensions, unemployment, health care, minimum wages and collective bargaining are national affairs.
This article appeared in the Europe section of the print edition under the headline "Protection racket"
Europe May 15th 2021
- Four decades after Mitterrand’s victory, France’s left is in trouble
- Bulgaria’s outgoing prime minister is under fire
- Plentiful renewable energy is opening up a new industrial frontier
- Pandemic tourism in Turkey
- The EU is trying to become a welfare superstate
- Can the European Union learn from its fiscal mistakes?
More from Europe
“Our Europe can die”: Macron’s dire message to the continent
Institutions are not for ever, after all
Carbon emissions are dropping—fast—in Europe
Thanks to a price mechanism that actually works
Italy’s government is trying to influence the state-owned broadcaster
Giorgia Meloni’s supporters accuse RAI of left-wing bias