Brief
Belonging to Europe
This paper is the English translation of an article published in the French review Etudes in Octobre 2021.
While membership of the EU is no longer called into question, including in France, we can still consider the full meaning of this sense of belonging. This requires holding together its cultural, institutional and political dimensions which are all too often fragmented, to give the European Union all the strength it needs in these demanding times.
The on-going French presidency of the Council of the European Union highlights European “belonging” in its motto. What kind of belonging is this? To what kind of Europe? Successive crises have challenged the complex links that connect us to the European Union (EU). The 2014-2015 migration crisis whose spectre has once again been raised, reminded Europeans that, in the eyes of the world, the EU represents a haven of peace, prosperity and freedom. It also betrayed European cultural insecurity in welcoming difference and an inability, still striking today, to work together as twenty-seven Member States on this politically thorny issue. Conversely, following an initial chaotic reaction, the recent health crisis showed the added value of cooperation and solidarity between countries, both for the vaccination campaign and for the ongoing economic recovery. Yet it was the Brexit crisis that posed the most direct and emotional challenge to the very meaning of the European Union, subjected to the voluntary and non-compelling departure of one of its very own members. The United Kingdom’s full withdrawal shattered the taboo of the irreversibility of European construction, while demonstrating preposterously its solidity through EU-27 cohesion that London never managed to undermine. Since then, Brexit has not heralded any other departures. Today, with very few exceptions, even the far right on the continent no longer calls into question the Euro, the Schengen Area and, more broadly, membership of the European Union.
The term “membership” is not restricted to the legal meaning of a Member State of the Union, enacted through an Accession Treaty. This treaty requires ratification that is often obtained by referendum, in which public acceptance, or rejection, of their country’s membership in the EU is expressed. The most recent referendum was conducted in 2012, when more than 66% of Croats voted in favour of membership in the European Union. Conversely, we remember the rejection by the people of Norway in 1972, repeated in another referendum in 1994. The most spectacular remains Brexit, pushed forward by a slim majority of British voters in 2016, putting an end to a membership which had been confirmed forty years earlier by the first referendum in the country’s history, in 1975, which experienceda higher turnout and where more than 67% voted in favour.
Belonging to Europe is never as clear-cut and binary as a referendum implies, however. It goes beyond the simple yet fundamental question of membership in the EU. Belonging is both individual and collective and, under all circumstances, subject to change. It draws, to varying degrees, from feelings, reason and conscience. Feelings govern the emotional attachment, reason assesses the benefits, while conscience brings together feelings and reason to grow a deep conviction.
This threefold approach to belonging meets a triple definition of Europe. The same word can refer to the continent and its civilisation, to the European Union as it functions today, and to a grand design, the plan for a united Europe, or in other words “making Europe”. Europe is addressed in different ways depending on its cultural, institutional and irenic aspects. To call oneself “European” may mean a cultural affiliation, acting, working, studying and consuming as an EU citizen or aspiring to the plan for a united Europe as a “committed” European.
Recommended citation:
Maillard S. 2022. “Belonging to Europe”, Policy brief, Jacques Delors Institute, February 2022.
SUR LE MÊME THÈME
ON THE SAME THEME
PUBLICATIONS
Declining birth rate in Europe

The true power of the EU is in transforming countries and lives

Newsletter June 2022

MÉDIAS
MEDIAS
L’Europe a-t-elle besoin d’une identité ?

“J’espère que l’Europe entière va éliminer ses frontières dans les semaines qui viennent”

“We have to reshape a transatlantic community”

ÉVÉNEMENTS
EVENTS
Euroquestions #69 | For an Energy Union 2.0. to implement the Green Pact [FR]

Euroquestions #62 | One year ahead of the 2024 European elections

Conférence Jacques Delors 2023 – La transition écologique [FR]

Building Europe differently [FR]

European Youth Forum [FR]

Saint James conversations : What will we do with Europe? [FR]

FOR A EUROPE OF CULTURE AND HERITAGE: FROM WORDS TO DEEDS [FR]

EUROPEAN DIPLOMACY AND THE UNION’S EXTERNAL ACTION [FR]

Conference TEDx Lannion | Europe with 3-Ds [FR]

Euroquestions | Représentation et participation : réinventer la démocratie en Europe

Euroquestions | Relance et puissance : mots d’ordre de la rentrée européenne

Des réponses européennes
à l’asile et aux migrations

Conférence
CEPS Ideas Lab

Strasbourg, 17th September 2019 – Democracy and the Peace Building process

Budapest, 10 to 14 July – Budapest European Agora

Avignon, 9 July 2019 – us, Europe

Paris, 21 June 2019 – Session 8: Europe of the Futur

Sion, 27 June 2019 – How to live in a citizen and brotherly Europe

Deauville, 27 April 2019 — Deauville Days : The future of Europe

Berlin, 26 April 2019 — Session of the Académie Notre Europe in Berlin

Paris, 2 April 2019 – Citizen And Trade Unionist: 2 Voices to Act For Europe

Paris, 29 January 2019 – Find the taste of European adventure

Paris, 29 January 2019 – Find the taste of European adventure

Amiens, 16 January 2019 – “Amiens plus grand” in Europe

Brussels, 7 December 2018 – Pays de la Loire in Europe

26 November 2018 – Round-table on Europe

Lourdes, 5 November 2018 – Identity and democracy, the future of Europe

Tournai, 27 October 2018 – Europe, I love you, me neither

Paris, 13 October 2018 – Citizen consultation: Is the EU condemned to powerlessness?

Brussels, 11 October 2018 – State of Europe 2018

Paris, 10 October 2018 – What is Europe for? Myths and realities

Paris, 4 October 2018 – Enrico Letta presents his book “Faire l’Europe dans un monde de brutes”

Paris, 2 October 2018 – Towards A New Capitalism: Fostering Inclusiveness

Paris, 18 September 2018 – A bike against Nazi barbarity

Neuilly-sur-Seine, 31 August 2018 – What Europe could bring to education and what education could bring to Europe?

Paris, 25 July 2018 – Salient European issues for 2019-2024

Bruges, 12 July 2018 – Negotiating the Energy Union

Paris, 11 July 2018 – Citizen consultation : what is Europe purpose?

Bruges, 3 July 2018 – Negotiating the Energy Union

Paris, 13 June 2018 – Whither European integration – Addressing EU internal and external challenges

Brussels, 7 June 2018 – Learning from experience and involving energy-citizens: two ways of improving energy-related policymaking

Paris, 6 June 2018 – Fact-finding mission on Europe “Achieve the democratic refounding process”

Strasbourg, 1st June 2018 – Europe on trial: Who’s to blame for the break-up?

Charbonnières les Bains, 22 May 2018 – Europe, Cosmopolitan democracy and the Professional world: is social harmonisation possible?

Paris, 16 May 2018 – Which values is the European Union bearing?

Florence, 10 May 2018 – New Forms of Markets and Solidarity Emerging in the EU Energy World

Paris, 9 May 2018 – Europe Day at school

Freiburg, 26 April 2018 – 11th Franco-German cultural meetings

Erasmus of Politics – Strasbourg cursus of the Académie Notre Europe trip to Rome

Sofia, 9 March 2018 – The future of the EU budget

Bordeaux, 25 January 2018 – 12th Franco-german dialogue

Paris, 12 February 2018 – Rebuilding Europe: what challenges?

Athens, 8 February 2018 – Athens’ days: Greece, paths for hope

Paris, 7 February 2018 – 59th Europartenaires Club

Paris, 7 February 2018 – Luncheon of the France-Italy Association

Paris, 5 February 2018 – European Awareness Day, Europe: what a Passion!

Paris, 2 February 2018 – How to deal with the populist phenomenon?

Brussels, 16 January 2018 – Europe’s challenges in 2018

Prague, 30 November 2017 – Debatting Europe

Blois, 22 November 2017 – Where is Europe heading toward?

Rome, 27-29 October 2017 – (Re)thinking Europe

Boulogne-Billancourt, 2 October 2017 – A New World?

Madrid, 22 September 2017 – Relaunching the European Union: A moment for action

Alpbach, 28 August, 2017 – The EU on trial: 60 years of conflict and cooperation in Europe

Oviedo, 25 July 2017 – Reply to the Euroskeptic

Prague, 8 June 2017 – Hamonization of EU social standards

Luxembourg, 3 May 2017 – What place for Europe in France? The citizens facing their responsibilities

Boulogne-Billancourt, 25 April 2017 – Europe: where do we go now?

Rodez, 20 April 2017 – Training about European issues

Paris, 22 March 2017 – Where is Europe heading to?

Berlin, 21 March 2017 – More capability to act through flexibility?

Brussels, 10 March 2017 – How to give body to the European project again?

Paris, 9 February 2017 – The Future of the Union

Paris, 26 January 2017, Commons for Europe

Brussels, 12 December 2016 – Yesterday’s and today’s European Union

Rotterdam, 21 November 2016 – Unity and efficiency

Paris, 24 October 2016 – Tribute to Emile Noël, Yesterday and today’s Europe

Paris, 8 September 2016 – A new territorial ambition for France in Europe
