Policy Paper 66
How to maintain hard capabilities in times of budget cuts?
Ronja Kempin, Head of Division, EU External Relations,SWP —
In times of financial crises and strained public budgets, many countries have decided to cut their defence spending. In order to maintain their hard capabilities despite this process, EU Member States should pool their resources and strive for closer cooperation on military and civilian matters. At this point in time, however, states seek their salvation in bilateral rather than European initiatives, as the Franco-British example shows. Strategic ambivalences and a lack of strategic clarity are the main reason for the CSDP not living up to its objectives. To overcome these obstacles, Member States must agree to substantially deepen their military and civilian collaboration. Most importantly, the EU must enter into a new strategising process to reformulate the scope and reach of cooperation on security and defence matters. Initiating this development and leading Member States towards a new reform agenda should be a top priority for the 2013 European Council.
This Policy Paper is a contribution of Ronja Kempin (SWP) to the project Think Global – Act European (TGAE). Thinking strategically about the EU’s external action directed by Notre Europe – Jacques Delors Institute (report available in March 2013, dir. Elvire Fabry, Senior Research Fellow, Notre Europe – Jacques Delors Institute).
In times of financial crises and strained
public budgets, many countries have decided to cut their defence spending. In
order to maintain their hard capabilities despite this process, EU Member
States should pool their resources and strive for closer cooperation on
military and civilian matters. At this point in time, however, states seek
their salvation in bilateral rather than European initiatives, as the
Franco-British example shows. Strategic ambivalences and a lack of strategic
clarity are the main reason for the CSDP not living up to its objectives. To
overcome these obstacles, Member States must agree to substantially deepen their
military and civilian collaboration. Most importantly, the EU must enter into a
new strategising process to reformulate the scope and reach of cooperation on
security and defence matters. Initiating this development and leading Member
States towards a new reform agenda should be a top priority for the 2013 European Council.
Before the
publication of the final report presenting the key recommendations of the 16
think tanks involved in the project, 5 series of Policy Papers address the following key challenges: CSDP, EU neighbourhood, strategic resources,
migration and economic policy.
“How can Europeans be taken seriously with lower hard capacities?” which
includes contributions by Jean-Pierre Darnis (IAI, Rome), Nick Witney (ECFR, London) Daniel Keohane (Fride, Brussels) and Jan Techau (Carnegie Europe,
Brussels).
The project is led with the support of the
SUR LE MÊME THÈME
ON THE SAME THEME
PUBLICATIONS
A new world order?

What security guarantees can the EU provide to Ukraine?

Victory, but what kind?

Whose leadership will emerge from the new European geopolitical situation?

Cyberattacks in Russia’s hybrid war against Ukraine

Which European defence policy?

Strategic Compass: industry or power?

European cybersecurity and data privacy:
Threats and prospects

From words to action

The budgetary stick to the rescue of the rule of law?

A historic agreement, to be improved and implemented

An ambitious recovery budget, tough negotiations ahead

Le covid-19 remet-il en cause l’Europe de la défense ?

The EU budget and COVID: We need a “plan B”

Covid-19 and the Mobilisation of Public Development Banks in the EU

Tackling the coronavirus crisis:
how can the EU budget help?

Fiscal policy-making in the time of Coronavirus

Coronavirus
krach financier et krach politique

Corona: A European Safety Net for the Fiscal Response

The Member State compartment of the InvestEU Fund:
how does it work? Will it fly?

MFF negotiations: towards the end?

L’armée européenne, y penser ?

‘No deal’ Brexit and the EU budget:
beware the risk for EU unity

An EU budget in support of the next commission’s agenda

Innovation for the energy & climate transition

European Budget 2021-2027: how to escape from “business as usual”?

Budget européen, retrouver le sens du long terme

Les Ateliers de la Citadelle

Negotiating the next Multi-Annual Financial Framework in an electoral year: which consequences?

InvestEU Fund: A Rebranded Juncker Fund?

Brexit: potential scenarios amid turbulent waters

Making better use of public funding: The role of national promotional banks and institutions in the next EU budget

The EU’s Four Strategic Challenges

Reinforcing the EU Budget with a fossil-fuel contribution

A European Defence Union: In the name of the people?

European Integration via Flexibility Tools: The Cases of EPPO and PESCO

The Next Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF) and its Flexibility

EU budget: What’s the Cost of Europe?

Understanding the “Brexit Divorce Bill”

Strengthening European Defence: who sits at the PESCO table, what’s on the menu?

The possible impact of Brexit on the EU budget and CAP funding

The EU as a 3-D Power: Should Europe Spend More on Diplomacy, Development and Defence?

Brexit and the Area of Freedom, Security and Justice

France and Germany: Spearheading a European Security and Defence Union?

Europe Facing the Challenge of Its Defence: Between Realism and Responsibility

Are the spending priorities of euro-area countries converging?

The future of the European budget: What does the Commission’s White Paper mean for EU finances?

Enrico Letta about the main issues of the June 2017 EU Council

Making the Energy Transition a European Success

Extending Erasmus: a new impetus for youth mobility in Europe

The Awakening

Brexit and the EU budget: threat or opportunity?

“Europeans’ fate is in their hands”

Strengthening European collective security

For an ambitious Europe

Building the future of the EU: our generation’s duty

Public Sector Reform: How the EU budget is used to encourage it

Investment in Europe: Making the best of the Juncker Plan

Is there an alternative to the European economic policy? The European Parliament response

Federalising the Eurozone: Towards a true European budget?

What European security and defence policy do we need?

European Defence Cooperation : speak the truth, act now

What would a European finance minister do? A proposal

On asylum and the euro: displaying solidarity is in our own interest

“Schengen”, terrorism and security

Resetting EU external action: potential and constraints

A new road map for the EU

The adjustements to the EU budget

Defence without Europe?

Defenceless Europe?

Why we should believe in European defence

National budgets and European surveillance: Shedding light on the debate

Reforming Europe’s governance

Should European defence be scrapped?

European security after Libya and Ukraine: in search of a core leadership

Engaging Europe in the world

Adjustment programmes in the euro area: mission accomplished?

Who calls the shots in the euro area? “Brussels” or the member states?

Europeans and the use of force

Foreign Policy and External Actions : an “unsurpassable horizon” for the EU?

Think Global – Act European IV. Thinking Strategically about the EU’s External Action

Non-Community European spending

Europe of Defence: A pragmatic approach

Think Global – Act European IV – Thinking Strategically about the EU’s External Action

Defence: The French ambition for Europe

EU budget: the path to an agreement

The role and place of Parliaments in a genuine Economic and Monetary Union

EU and growth: three pacts rather than one

European budget 2014-2020: seven years of bad luck?

Is the stupidity pact still stable?

Will Europeans ever agree on the use of military force?

Strategic Priorities for EU Defence Policy

The European Defence Industry’s Future: How European?

The EU budget: taking a second look

Welfare state sustainability: resetting EU migration strategy?

EU defence capacities: maintaining credibility?

Britain and Europe – The last rites?

Spending better together: analyses and recommendations

Reforming the EU budget in times of crisis

Eurozone budget: 3 functions, 3 instruments

Which Institutions for the Euro Area?

“Fiscal Compact”, sovereignty and austerity

What European budget for post-crisis Europe?

European Development Aid: How to be more effective without spending more?

European guarantees to get out of the crisis?

The European “Fiscal Compact”: a goal or a starting point?

EU budget negotiations: need for a healthy and constructive debate

Europe abroad : twenty years after Maastricht, is there anybody there ?

The “Fiscal Compact”: legal uncertainty and political ambiguity

The ‘TSCG’: much ado about nothing?

A two-pronged defence of the Euro

The Common Strategic Framework: adding value to rural development?

Debt crisis, sovereignty crisis

The CAP in the EU Budget: New Objectives and Financial Principles for the Agricultural Budget after 2013

Rethinking EU finances in times of crisis

Thinking the EU budget and public spending in Europe: the need to use an aggregate approach

Defence spending in Europe: Can we do better without spending more?

The “added value” in EU budgetary debates: one concept, four meanings

Report Haug, Lamassoure, Verhofstadt: Europe for Growth : Towards a radical change in financing the EU

Options for an EU Financing Reform

Comments on the CEPS policy brief “A new Budget for the European Union?”
