Other document
Reaction of James Fishkin to Andrew Moravcsik’s article on the collapse of the Constitutional treaty
Moravcsik’s critique of EU popular consultation concentrates especially on two causal connections he regards as dubious: First that “greater participation generates more informed deliberation ” and second that “more informed or intensive decision-making generates greater public trust and a deeper sense of common identity and legitimacy”.
Moravcsik’s
critique of EU popular consultation concentrates especially on two causal
connections he regards as
dubious: First that “greater participation generates more informed
deliberation.” and second that
“more informed or intensive decision-making generates greater public trust
and a deeper sense of common
identity and legitimacy” (p. 222). The supposed flaws in these
propositions undermine the notion that
“more populist and deliberative democratic forms” will “generate
participation and legitimacy” (p.221).
The basic
difficulty with this critique is that it fails to distinguish
“populist” from “deliberative” forms of democracy.
Indeed, the argument seems to treat them as nearly interchangeable. Our
research raises serious
questions about Moravcsik’s critique. We agree that many populist forms of
participation will do nothing for
deliberation. It all depends on institutional design (see Fishkin, Democracy
and Deliberation, Yale
University Press, 1991). Unthinking mobilization is not deliberation.Talking to the likeminded is not deliberation.
Careful structuring is required for an informed and civil exchange of views. With proper
design, we have found in Deliberative Polling research that deliberation
contributes to virtually
all of the desired aspects of citizenship. Hence we believe that Moravcsik’s
third proposition is open to
serious question (see Luskin and Fishkin, “Deliberation and Better
Citizens” on http://cdd.stanford.edu for evidence of the
effects of deliberation on several dimensions of citizenship). And in the
1995 British Deliberative Poll on EU issues, we found that citizen deliberation
increased support for
Britain’s integration into the EU. Hence Moravcsik is not correct that social
science research routinely supports the
notion that public discussion will necessarily decrease the legitimacy of the
European Union. These are
open, empirical questions. Sometimes deliberative public discussion has clearly
increased it.
We agree
that increasing populism may not serve deliberation. If there had been
something more recognizable
as citizen deliberation on the constitution, then perhaps some of the other
aims of EU citizenship
would have been achieved. Our experiments with Deliberative Polling certainly
suggest that. Hence
televised microcosmic deliberation combined with appropriate strategies for
extending the reach of such efforts
to the broader public might have led to a different debate and perhaps a
different outcome. In any case, a
retreat to an elites-only discussion will not serve EU legitimacy, while
movement toward deliberative
involvement by the public, rather than merely populist involvement, may do so.
SUR LE MÊME THÈME
ON THE SAME THEME
PUBLICATIONS
[FR] THE MOLDAVIANS AND THE EU: A STILL TIMID EUROFAVOUR
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/blogpostbleu.png)
[FR] In the minds of the Balkans
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/blogpostbleu.png)
[FR] Europe retains public favor in the face of the war in Ukraine
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
[FR] European opinions on the war in Ukraine
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
FRENCH-STYLE EUROSCEPTICISM
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/rapportbleu.png)
EUROPEAN PUBLIC OPINION IN A TROUBLED 2020
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
French public opinion and Europe
between distrust and ambivalence
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/blogpostbleu.png)
Public opinion in Greece & the EU
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/blogpostbleu.png)
Brexit has not won over european opinions, quite the contrary
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/blogpostbleu.png)
The political climate in spain ahead of the elections
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
Appartenance assumée, adhésion réservée : évolution des opinions publiques sur l’Union européenne – de la crise à nos jours
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/blogpostbleu.png)
Expectations and feelings, the state of public opinion before the European elections
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
The Spanish public opinions and the EU
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
They Love Me, They Love Me Not, They Love Me a Little: Public Opinion and the European Union in the Visegrad Countries
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
Allegro ma non troppo: European public opinions at the end of 2017
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
Italy’s Euroscepticism: A case of Victimhood and a Tale of Missed Opportunity
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
The Italians and Europe, Chronicle of Disenchantment
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
Europe, Germany, France: Evolution of Public Opinions
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
European public opinion and the EU following the peak of the migration crisis
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
European Democracy: What Are the Next Challenges
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Social Networks and Populism in the EU : Comparative Study
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
National Referendums on EU Issues: from Clarification to Frustration
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
Living Together Facing Fears: the French Political Dilemma
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
Brexit: between British Europhobia and continental Euroscepticisms
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
The EU and referenda: three denials of democracy
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
The EU, despite everything? European public opinion in the face of crisis (2005–2015)
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/rapportbleu.png)
TTIP and German opinion’s legitimate fears
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
The EU and referenda: structural incompatibility?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
2014 European elections: an upsurge in Europhobia or business as usual?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
Tsipras is not Midas: a break in continuity?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
Euroscepticism or Europhobia: voice vs. exit?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
The EU and referenda on independence: a leap in the dark?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
European elections: What form of cohabitation between France and the EU?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
What the French told us about the employement in the EU
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
What the French told us about the European democracy
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
What the French told us about euro
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
What the French told us about globalisation
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Power to the citizens: Conditions for a European public space?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
European Elections : less abstention, more populism?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Making the EU more democratic
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Beyond the Troika: which divides and faces for the EU?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Leading Europe from the front
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
EU no, euro yes? European public opinions facing the crisis (2007-2012)
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
Consolidating the EMU, a vital task
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Britain and Europe – The last rites?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
“Germany strongly evolved during the crisis”
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
Brussels, 2 May 2012 – What Are the Risks of Small Steps in a Rapidly Changing World?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Do the Europeans still believe in the EU?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/rapportbleu.png)
Public Opinion and the Eurozone Crisis – PEW Global Attitudes Survey
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
The European Union in touch with its citizens: the analytical tools of public opinion
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
The Citizens of Europe and the European Union in the Current Crisis
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
The European Union and the challenges of populism
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
Where is Germany Heading?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/rapportbleu.png)
Listening to Europe’s citizens. An assessment of the first experiments in participation organised at EU level
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
Propositions by French civil society to national and European decision-makers
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
From institutional Reform to Mass Politics or How to Engage Citizens in the Union of Lisbon
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
European political parties: the missing link
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
We shall bring you our vices
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Does the Union’s Action Meet the Citizen’s Preferences ?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/decryptagebleu.png)
How to Explain the Unexpected: An Assessment of the French Constitutional Referendum
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
European Estates General: 3000 participants relaunch the debate
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Towards a European public space? The European elections on June 2004
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/rapportbleu.png)
A Citizens Compact: Reaching out to the Citizens of Europe
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
Constitutional referendum in France: a mid-term assessment
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Landscape after the battle
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Letter to our European friends who want to Vote not
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
The Impact of the Television Media on the French Referendum Campaign in 2005
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/rapportbleu.png)
Reaction of Pepper D. Culpepper and Archon Fung to Andrew Moravcsik’s article on the collapse of the Constitutional treaty
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Reaction of Paul Magnette to Andrew Moravcsik’s article on the collapse of the Constitutional treaty
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Can you imagine a referendum to European level and under what conditions?
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
The European Debate in Sweden
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/rapportbleu.png)
Local development, partnership and bottom-up approach
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Referenda in other countries: the case of Spain
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
The First Dutch Referendum: a pre-ballot assessment
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
The European Constitution and deliberation: the Example of deliberative focus groups ahead of the French Referendum of 29 May 2005
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/rapportbleu.png)
Democratising European Democracy
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
The French “no” vote of 29 May 2005: understand, act
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/rapportbleu.png)
Securing a “Yes”: from Nice I to Nice II
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/policypaperbleu.png)
“The Constitution, a step forward for the European Union” intervention by Jacques Delors
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/autredocumentbleu.png)
Ratification and Revision of the Consitutional Treaty
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/rapportbleu.png)
European attitudes towards transatlantic relations 2000-2003: an analytical survey
![](https://institutdelors.eu/wp-content/themes/Avada-Child-Theme/images/rapportbleu.png)