Blog post
Reforming the WTO – with or without the US?
Washington’s continued block of the process to fill vacant Appellate Body seats must be framed in the big picture of systemic trade distortions, says Elvire Fabry, senior research fellow at the Jacques Delors Institute, who argues that what is at stake are the gaps in multilateral rule that allow distortions such as Chinese subsidies to state-owned enterprises. She presents several options to keep dispute settlement functional.
On the same topic, see “Saving the WTO Appellate Body or Returning to the Wild West of Trade?“, Policy Paper by Elvire Fabry.
Threats, blackmail and martial confrontation are President Donald Trump’s policy tools in both geo-economics and geopolitics. But beyond the short-term negotiation strategy of trying to destabilise the other party, will he be able to manage the systemic shockwaves that this is creating?
It is not yet clear whether Trump intends to disengage the US from global value chains by building protectionist walls – from adding investment restrictions and export controls to imposing higher tariffs on imports, targeting China and other countries. Or is he willing to flip up the table of multilateralism to trade more fruitfully in what would have then turned into a Wild West of trade? In both cases, suspicion and fear will develop and could eventually contaminate the world.
Trump was elected on the promise of a new future for the American middle class, increasingly challenged by the development of a global middle class, notably in Asia. Yet, instead of developing welfare-state policies to help people adapt to the new challenges of globalisation – including data transfer, e-commerce and artificial intelligence – he seems happy to increase the distrust in global interdependence, with unknown consequences in the US and abroad.
With the US withdrawing further from multilateralism, one can only hope that Europeans will not also retreat from the promotion of a more regulated globalisation. There is obviously a fatigue about multilateralism. But the cornerstone of the regulation of international trade, namely the World Trade Organization’s dispute settlement mechanism, could soon be blocked if Washington continues to oppose the appointment of new judges to the Appellate Body.
The issue needs to be framed in the big picture of systemic trade distortions. Beyond a mere procedural reform of the Appellate Body, what is at stake here are the gaps in multilateral rules that allow distortions such as Chinese subsidies to state-owned enterprises.
Pushing China to the negotiating table
Will Beijing’s apparent commitment to the multilateral system pave the way for so-called constructive confrontation? Bringing China to the negotiating table remains a challenge. But restoring confidence in fair trade requires strengthening the two legs of the WTO: litigation and negotiation.
The European Commission must be supported in its initiative to create a coalition calling for WTO reform to save the dispute settlement mechanism. The pressure on Beijing to come to the negotiation table could and should be shared among a larger group of countries, as so many – particularly developing economies – will likely be penalised by the bilateral confrontation between the US and China.
A first step in the right direction would consist of countering subsidy notification failures: ensuring that WTO members comply with the requirements on subsidy notifications. Compliance levels with transparency obligations are low and decreasing since 1995 – with the percentage of members reporting subsidies falling from 50% to 38% today.[1]
Amending the Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures may well be a long process – in particular, as regards the “less than adequate remunerations” through which the Chinese government supports companies. Europeans and the other members of the WTO cannot accept being held hostage by the US threat to block the dispute settlement mechanism. A strong coalition of WTO members is needed to adopt emergency measures to preserve a functional dispute settlement capacity, without the United States if necessary.
What can be done?
Several options could be considered:
– the “nuclear option” of a qualified majority to appoint new judges to the Appellate Body;
– recourse to an ad hoc arbitration system, already authorised by Article 25 of the Dispute Settlement Understanding, as a transition phase;
– replicate the Appellate Body’s procedures in a separate agreement, signed by a “coalition of the willing” determined to preserve the balance of international commerce without renegotiating the entire trade regime. This agreement would then take effect only if the US blocked the Appellate Body by not allowing vacancies to be filled before December 2019. This would move the dispute settlement mechanism out of the WTO, but would show willingness to preserve a multilateral system.
As Trump’s vision remains focused on the short term and is primarily influenced by the US mid-term elections in the autumn, it will be up to the other major trading powers, including the EU, to keep multilateral regulation alive.
Elvire Fabry
previously published in Borderlex
[1] “Improving disciplines on subsidies notification”, TN/RL/GEN/188, WTO, 2017.
SUR LE MÊME THÈME
ON THE SAME THEME
PUBLICATIONS
EU and China between De-Risking and Cooperation: Scenarios by 2035

Mapping the EU’s digital trade

Making migrant returns a pre-condition of trade openness

MÉDIAS
MEDIAS
L’OMC, paralysée, joue son avenir à Genève

N.Gnesotto – “Quel impact de l’affaire des sous-marins australiens ?”

L’acier et l’aluminium réchauffent les relations transatlantiques

Accès aux marchés publics : comment l’Europe veut riposter face à la Chine

Mondialisation, Chine… comment l’équilibre du monde a basculé depuis 30 ans

France eyes big leap to join Germans in trade surplus club

Pénuries : l’épine dans le pied de la reprise mondiale

Tournant entre l’Europe et les Etats-Unis sur le conflit des avionneurs

La détente commerciale entre Europe et Etats-Unis reste fragile

Les Européens et Joe Biden veulent enterrer la hache de guerre commerciale

Un rapprochement UE-États-Unis par l’exemple

European-style carbon taxes destined to spread, says former trade chief

Vaccins anti-COVID : l’Europe durcit le ton

Expertos ven un continuismo reformista en la política de Biden hacia la UE

«L’UE sera plus offensive sur ses valeurs et plus défensive sur ses intérêts»

Verdir la mondialisation: un défi de taille pour l’UE

Europe, une nouvelle politique commerciale

Morning Trade: Mixed or not — Trade policy review

Les messages d’adieu de Michel Barnier à l’Union européenne

Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, première femme à la tête de l’OMC

La Nigériane Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala devient la première femme et la première Africaine à la tête de l’Organisation mondiale du commerce

Brexit – Rendez-vous avec Bernard Volker

La Nigériane Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, seule en lice à l’OMC

Inside the Brexit deal: the agreement and the aftermath

Donald Trump n’a pas réussi sa guerre commerciale

Guerre commerciale : l’Europe s’arme enfin

“Biden ne va pas manipuler l’arme tarifaire comme Donald Trump

Présidentielle américaine: pas de changement de fond attendu sur le front commercial

Peut-on réformer l’Organisation mondiale du commerce?

La fin de l’interminable feuilleton des subventions pour Airbus et Boeing

Any Question’s

Can the coronavirus bring back Europe’s pharmaceutical factories?

Commerce : Roberto Azevedo quitte la direction d’une OMC en crise

L’UE veut protéger son marché des appétits chinois

Le nouveau visage de la mondialisation après la pandémie

“La construction européenne sortira de cette crise, ou bien renforcée, ou bien affaiblie.”

Démondialisation ? « ‘précautionnisme’ plutôt que ‘protectionnisme’»

“Je ne crois pas à la déglobalisation”

Donald Trump’s policies on trade do not work

Nueva cuenta atrás para evitar una ruptura caótica

«Sur la sortie juridique du R-U, l’épreuve de force avec l’UE ne fait que commencer»

Europe Is the New Front in Trump’s Trade War

“Côté américain, comme côté européen, on pratique les subventions depuis longtemps”

Nouvelle phase du Brexit : “il n’y a pas de stratégie claire derrière”

Brexit, “On en est qu’au début..”

“Le commerce international doit valoriser une économie qui protège les ressources naturelles”

« À l’heure de la connectivité mondiale [..] plus de régulation multilatérale » est nécessaire

Organe d’appel de l’OMC : « Ce système permet d’éviter le far west commercial »

“The WTO needs both its legs, litigation and negotiation”

Brexit : « D’après la déclaration politique on sent [..] une volonté de divergence importante avec l’Europe »

“Pour l’UE, il s’agit […] d’empêcher un retour au Far West du commerce international”

“Les États-Unis ont une main très tendue vers Londres pour un rapprochement rapide”

“the UK-EU trade deal will not be an ordinary one”

Boris Johnson « ne veut pas laisser le temps qui faut pour relancer encore le débat au sein des parlementaires »

Il faut “avant tout qu’on soit dans l’Europe en se sentant européens”

“Aujourd’hui, le défi américain c’est de vouloir, non seulement contenir la puissance de la Chine, mais au contraire la repousser”

Derrière l’affaire Airbus, la guerre commerciale américano-européenne

Les États-Unis prêts à taxer les produits européens

Conflit Airbus/Boeing : “Une absurdité”

“L’Europe est une construction politique extrêmement ambitieuse”

“Il faut aller plus loin et faire de l’accord de Paris une clause essentielle”

Guerre commerciale : « L’Europe peut encore peser »

“Les taxes américaines couvrent désormais la quasi-totalité des importations chinoises”

The G7 summit gets underway in France

Pascal Lamy “very worried” Japan is using trade to address an essentially “political problem” of colonial reparation.

Mercosur : Pascal Lamy répond à l’édito de Pascal Riché

Des pistes pour verdir le commerce mondial

La mondialisation économique est-elle inéluctable ?

Accords Mercosur et Ceta

Le nouveau traité de libre-échange transatlantique, déjà mort-né…

« Mettre le commerce au service de l’environnement »

“Le Mercosur va empêcher M. Bolsonaro de déforester l’Amazonie”

“Europe’s trade policy needs to get greener”

Pascal Lamy : « Quand on perd du poids, il faut gagner du muscle »

“Il est trop tôt pour juger si les turbulences que connait le commerce mondial sont l’amorce d’un changement d’un modèle”

China – US trade policy briefing

Pascal Lamy invited on l’heure H on BFM : what place for Europe between sino-american tensions ?

Pascal Lamy on Reuters News: “the overall consensus that globalisation is the way to go is somehow fractured”

Marie-Hélène Bérard presents “L’Europe face aux sanctions américaines, quelle souveraineté pour l’Europe ?” on BFM Business

Pascal Lamy to El Pais: “Tenemos que proteger más al individuo y menos el empleo”

Pascal Lamy in Le Monde on a possible European answer to american extraterritoriality

Pascal Lamy on CNBC : “WTO reform is now on the table”

Elvire Fabry : “If the appeal body is paralysed, WTO members will be free of multilateral rules.”

Eulalia Rubio, senior researcher at the Jacques Delors Institute, debates on European economic governance on Radio Television Española

Mario Draghi on the single market and the eurozone : preaching in the desert

Elvire Fabry on the trade war and the worries of European businesses

Mario Draghi : “The most important area where Europe can contribute positively to growth remains the single market.”

Mario Draghi calls for euro area fiscal instrument to fight crises.

Pascal Lamy : « L’OMC doit pouvoir exister sans Donald Trump »

Trump’s National Security Claim for Tariffs Sets Off Crisis at W.T.O.

„Wir müssen Druck auf China ausüben“

EACC Insights: Is Trump Aiming to DEglobalize Us?

“Prepare for the worst” in case of a no-deal Brexit – former WTO chief

What did Trump and Juncker agree on trade?

Former WTO head Lamy hails ‘good ceasefire’ on US-EU trade

“L’opinion américaine a fait changer d’avis Trump sur les taxes douanières”

“Juncker doit convaincre Trump de pousser pour que la Chine accepte des règles contraignantes”

Rencontre Trump-Juncker : le président américain “a une idée du commerce international qui ressemble à ce qui se passait au Moyen Âge”

As tensions with US worsen, Europe courts new partners

La OTAN bajo Trump

L’isolement américain

Morning news and current affairs

“La guerre commerciale ne devrait pas dégénérer”, estime Pascal Lamy

Repenser la mondialisation face à l’orage populiste

Comment la Chine a dupé Américains et Européens à l’OMC

Former director-general of the WTO: WTO needs reform and modernization

Deux ans après, le Brexit continue de tirailler le Royaume-Uni

La mondialisation sera plus forte que Trump, selon Pascal Lamy

Pascal Lamy : « Trump ne pourra pas mettre fin à la globalisation »

Bruxelas prepara reforço da indústria europeia de defesa

“Trump veut démolir l’ordre international”

Global trade dispute set for G7 summit showdown

Trump au G7 : les alliés se rebiffent

La guerre commerciale avec les USA

Les relations transatlantiques

Commerce mondial : pourquoi Trump risque de mettre l’Europe hors jeu
