Policy paper 158
Schengen’s stress test: political issues and perspectives
This policy paper by António Vitorino and Yves Bertoncini analyse the civic and diplomatic roots of the crisis in the Schengen area in order to diagnose its scale and to identify a potential way out over the coming months.
António Vitorino and Yves Bertoncini analyse the civic and diplomatic roots of the crisis in the Schengen area in order to diagnose its scale and to identify a potential way out over the coming months. Their policy paper combines three sets of political statements and recommendations:
1. Schengen under fire from opposing political visions
– While all of the Europeans agree on perceiving Islamist terrorism as a threat, some of them can perceive asylum-seekers as “victims” and others as a threat.
– “Schengen” is caught in a cross-fire between national political representations that overrate the real protective potential of borders, and pro-European representations that play down the original agreement’s security-related aspects and the popular dimension of free movement.
– “Schengen bashing” is used by national authorities eager to offload their own failings and responsibilities as regards the evolution of the refugee crisis and in the face of terrorist threats.
2. A crisis in solidarity, but primarily a crisis in trust, on the verge of being reduced?
– The construction of “hotspots” has the merit of responding at once to the lack of solidarity and to the lack of trust among the Schengen area’s member states – as will the “European Border and Coast Guard” project.
– The terror threat triggers a far more emotion-based solidarity among European countries, facilitating the adoption of security measures at the EU level, but how is it possible to achieve a fluid and fruitful exchange of information among European countries that continue to spy on one another?
– There is a race against time, to end in 2018, between the Europeanisation of external border monitoring and the temporary reintroduction of national border controls, which is an implementation and not a “suspension” of Schengen code;
– Are the Europeans going to hold to a position seeking to maintain the rights associated with Schengen’s membership (more freedom and police and judicial cooperation) while agreeing to shoulder more of the duties that go with that (in terms both of solidarity and of border control)?
3. More Europe on the borders, but also beyond: a sovereignty issue
– The creation of “hotspots” and the relocation of asylum-seekers must be presented as crisis-management tools justifying the shared exercise of sovereignty in order for them to be more effective and to enjoy greater legitimacy.
– There is a need to act within a “shared sovereignty” area in which everyone and everything moves about freely, including jihadist terrorists and human trafficking networks, but not police officers and not the intelligence that those officers possess.
– Pressure will continue to bear down on the Schengen area until the Europeans prove capable of preventing and controlling crises occurring in their neighbourhood: acting on our borders won’t be efficient, only “Europe power” can contribute to Schengen’s rescue.
António Vitorino and Yves Bertoncini conclude their policy paper by underlinining that It is way too soon to announce the death of “Schengen”, just as it proved way too soon to announce the “Grexit” in 2015 – and that it is even possible that the crisis in the Schengen area may have a similar outcome to the crisis in the euro area, then leading to more European solidarity and control.
SUR LE MÊME THÈME
ON THE SAME THEME
PUBLICATIONS
The four freedoms in the EU: Are they inseparable?

Brexit and the Area of Freedom, Security and Justice

Free movement of Europeans – Taking stock of a misunderstood right

MÉDIAS
MEDIAS
Migrations : l’Europe veut une meilleure protection de ses frontières

Au col de Banyuls, passage interdit entre la France et l’Espagne

Les Vingt-Sept veulent accélérer le retour des migrants irréguliers vers leur pays

Migrants : la France espère une sortie de crise à Bruxelles

Migrants : que vont devenir les rescapés de l’Ocean Viking ?

L’Union européenne n’est « ni une forteresse, ni une passoire »

Touristes russes dans l’UE : que change la suspension de l’accord sur les visas ?

L’interdiction des visas russes, nouveau terrain de division de l’Union européenne

Interdire les touristes russes ? “L’intérêt de l’UE n’est pas de s’aliéner 146 millions de gens”

L’Union européenne doit-elle interdire l’entrée des touristes russes sur son territoire ?

Malgré les efforts français, le Pacte asile et migration toujours dans le flou

Faut-il réformer Schengen?

Schengen, asile, migration: Macron revient à la charge

Sur l’immigration, Emmanuel Macron veut tirer profit de la présidence française de l’Union européenne

Migrations: la fermeture des frontières, seul consensus européen

Réforme de l’espace Schengen: l’UE «va se donner les moyens de vérification»

Un «Accord Schengen pour les migrations», la proposition choc soumise à Emmanuel Macron qui pourrait concerner la Suisse

Accord migratoire UE-Turquie: un pis aller qui s’éternise

Contrôles aux frontières en Europe : un espace Schengen en peau de chagrin

Covid-19. Efficacité, légalité… Les questions que pose la fermeture des frontières en Allemagne

Covid-19 : la fermeture des frontières allemandes inquiète la France et la Commission européenne

Covid-19 : en fermant ses frontières, l’Allemagne accentue la “totale cacophonie entre les Etats européens”, critique un chercheur

UE : des décisions en commun sur le retour des frontières

«En fermant l’accès, on permet aux réseaux parallèles de prospérer»

Pacte migratoire : les pays du sud sauveront-il le principe de solidarité ?

Migration et asile: l’Europe de l’impuissance

Immigration: le coup de pression de Macron sur l’Italie

Déconfinement en Europe : une réouverture des frontières en ordre dispersé

Réouverture des frontières : « Si on ne peut pas circuler librement en Europe, il n’y a pas d’Europe »

“J’espère que l’Europe entière va éliminer ses frontières dans les semaines qui viennent”

“Plus la situation est exceptionnelle, plus le recours à la souveraineté s’accroît”

L’avenir de l’Europe passe-t-il par le retour des frontières ?

The Jacques Delors’ Institute’s report on the “liberté de circulation des Européens” quoted in Marianne

The Schengen area and the extension of the border control within the EU – Yves Pascouau dans Le Monde

The European system of asylum seekers – Yves Pascouau in La Croix

EU’s external border controls – Yves Pascouau Le Monde

The fear of a militarisation of the borders – Yves Pascouau on Deutsche Welle

Yves Pascouau on France Culture about the Schengen area

Yves Pascouau on RFI: “Sécurité: faut-il rétablir le contrôle aux frontières intérieures de l’UE?”

Yves Pascouau on the morning programme of Europe1: all is done to save Schengen
