Report
Social Competition in the EU: Myths and Realities
K. Maslauskaite presents this study that aims at providing a global analysis of the various existing components of social competition in the EU in order to see whether the differences between member states leave enough space to generate a generalised “social dumping”.
Social Competition in the EU: Myths and Realities
The debate on social competition, or social dumping, is as old as the European Union itself, yet it has been getting louder in the recent years marked by economic turmoil and high levels of unemployment in many of the member states. Public opinion and politicians are worried that intense competition in the cost of labour between the member states might result in the “race to the bottom” in terms of social standards.
This Study by K. Maslauskaite aims at providing a global analysis of the various existing components of social competition in the EU in order to see whether the differences between member states leave enough space for engaging in a generalised “social dumping”. Due to the size limitations, only the general trends on the national level have been observed using the most relevant empirical data.
Overall, the analysis reveals some intriguing developments and shows that, generally speaking, there is little space for regime competition between the European “core” and the “new” member states. For example, in terms of productivity-adjusted total labour cost, some of the new member states have not only lost their status of the cheap labour destination, but have also become more expensive than the European core.
Unexpectedly, three member states not belonging to the Central and Easter European club, namely the UK, Ireland and to some extent Luxembourg, seem to consistently outperform all the other countries in terms of real labour cost both in direct and indirect terms. In this sense, these countries could be considered as the most realistic suspects of “social dumping”. It does not automatically follow that these member states do engage in social dumping though; it only implies that their economic model is the most efficient in terms of labour cost. After all, as discussed in the Study, disloyal and genuine welfare-enhancing competition might be sometimes difficult to disentangle, which makes the argument of “social dumping” difficult to prove.
SUR LE MÊME THÈME
ON THE SAME THEME
PUBLICATIONS
Regional risk of poverty in the EU-27

Blog post
04/10/2024 |
Making the most of the European Year of Skills

Blog post
05/05/2023 | Sofia Fernandes |
Parents’ leaves in the EU

Infographic
05/07/2022 | Klervi Kerneïs |
One step closer to adequate minimum wages in the EU

Blog post
15/06/2022 | Klervi Kerneïs |
Young people’s attitudes towards the EU

Infographic
25/05/2022 | Klervi Kerneïs | Sofia Fernandes |
Towards a European individual learning account

Brief
30/04/2021 | Sofia Fernandes | Klervi Kerneïs |
Towards an individual right to adult learning for all europeans

Other document
02/12/2020 | Sofia Fernandes | Klervi Kerneïs |
Harmful tax competition

Blog post
10/09/2020 |
Combating poverty in Europe

Blog post
05/06/2020 | Julien Damon |
Objective 2024: better living and working conditions for all europeans

Blog post
02/09/2019 | Sofia Fernandes |
La Cour de Justice de l’UE et la Pologne : premiers frémissements

Blog post
10/08/2018 | Martin Michelot |
Family allowances: their amount should not depend on the country where the child lives

Brief
19/04/2018 | Sofia Fernandes | Justine Daniel |
What is our Ambition for the European Labour Authority?

Policy Paper
09/03/2018 | Sofia Fernandes |
Reinforcing the EU Budget with a fossil-fuel contribution

Blog post
20/02/2018 | Enrico Letta | Pascal Lamy |
Posted Workers: How to Ensure a Fair Mobility?

Brief
20/10/2017 | Sofia Fernandes |
Extending Erasmus: a new impetus for youth mobility in Europe

Policy Paper
14/06/2017 | Yves Bertoncini | Sofia Fernandes |
Making Social Europe a Reality for European Citizens

Other document
30/05/2017 | Sofia Fernandes | Frank Vandenbroucke |
Narrating Social Europe: the Search for progress in the “Age of Delors”

Policy Paper
07/02/2017 | Alessandra Bitumi |
For an ambitious Europe

Other document
08/11/2016 | Jean-Claude Juncker |
Automatic stabilizers for the Euro area and the European social model

Other document
22/09/2016 | Frank Vandenbroucke |
Is there such a thing as “Social Europe”?

Other document
06/09/2016 | Sofia Fernandes | David Rinaldi |
Social benefits and cross-border mobility

Other document
12/07/2016 | Frank Vandenbroucke |
Access to social benefits for EU mobile citizens: “tourism” or myth?

Policy Paper
30/06/2016 | Sofia Fernandes |
The growing intergenerational divide in Europe – What role for the welfare state?

Policy Paper
09/02/2016 | Pia Hüttl | Guntram Wolff |
A new start for Social Europe

Report
Governing the welfare state and beyond – Solutions for a complex and uncertain future

Policy Paper
02/02/2016 | Eeva Hellström | Mikko Kosonen |
Redesigning European welfare states – Time for action

Blog post
02/12/2015 | Robin Niblett | Yves Bertoncini |
Social inequalities in Europe: the challenge of convergence and cohesion

Policy Paper
02/12/2015 | Frank Vandenbroucke | David Rinaldi |
The Future of the Welfare State : visions for reform

Policy Paper
Growth and euro area stability: for a deepened single market for services

Other document
26/06/2015 | Anna auf dem Brinke | Jörg Haas |
Regional integration and social cohesion: the European experience

Policy Paper
25/06/2015 | Eulalia Rubio |
European social dialogue: 30 years of experience and progress, what future?

Policy Paper
28/01/2015 | Jean Lapeyre |
Employment, mobility and social investment: three key issues for post-crisis social Europe

Policy Paper
14/11/2014 | Sofia Fernandes |
Who calls the shots in the euro area? “Brussels” or the member states?

Policy Paper
14/05/2014 | Sofia Fernandes |
Posted workers in the EU: state of play and regulatory evolution

Policy Paper
24/03/2014 | Kristina Maslauskaite |
What kind of Social Europe after the crisis?

Other document
04/02/2014 | Sofia Fernandes | Emanuel Gyger |
Social Competition in the EU: Myths and Realities

Report
09/10/2013 | Kristina Maslauskaite |
What are the economic and social issues of the 2014 European elections?

Other document
01/10/2013 | Sofia Fernandes |
Towards a more social Europe?

Other document
11/07/2013 | Marie Billotte | Sofia Fernandes |
Averting two pitfalls: illusion and inertia

Blog post
25/06/2013 | António Vitorino |
Social Competition in the EU: Myths and Realities

Report
05/06/2013 | Kristina Maslauskaite |
A European statute for mutuals?

Other document
26/10/2012 | Eulalia Rubio |
Europe 2020 : l’urgence d’impliquer les porteurs de stratégie

Brief
16/06/2010 | Elvire Fabry | Sofia Fernandes |
Social Europe and the crisis: Defining a new Agenda

Policy Paper
06/05/2009 | Eulalia Rubio |
Social experimentation in Europe: Towards a more complete and effective palette of the EU action for social innovation

Report
20/11/2008 | Marjorie Jouen | Jacques Delors |
Social Protection: why the EU needs to deliver?

Other document
24/06/2008 | Renaud Dehousse |
Contribution to the consultation on “Europe’s social reality”

Other document
19/02/2008 | Marjorie Jouen |
A Policy in its Infancy: The case for strengthening and re-thinking EU action on childhood

Policy Paper
24/10/2007 | Eulalia Rubio |
Towards a new social contract in Europe. France-Germany economic changes and social models

Other document
20/05/2007 |
Lack of Economic Growth and Unemployment: the cost of non coopération

Blog post
28/02/2007 | Pierre-Alain Muet | Jacques Delors |
What stability pact for Europe?

Policy Paper
04/01/2007 | Hugo de Sousa |
Evolution of Economic and Social Cohesion to the Future Widening

Other document
27/12/2006 | Jacques Delors |
To make large Europe a space of Solidarity and Cooperation

Other document
27/12/2006 | Jacques Delors |
An Economy with the Dimension of the person

Other document
27/12/2006 | Jacques Delors |
Summary Workshop “The European Social Model(s): which directions and responsibilities for the EU?”

Other document
28/08/2006 | Tommaso Padoa-Schioppa |
National social pacts

Other document
17/08/2006 | Jacques Delors |
A reappraisial of Europe’s social model

Other document
17/08/2006 | Jacques Delors |
Towards a rethinking of the national systems of social protections? Observations on the recent jurisprudence of the Court of Justice

Report
17/08/2006 | Alessandra Bosco | Jacques Delors |
Is the Juice worth the Squeeze?

Other document
14/06/2006 | Teresa Bomba |
For a new European social contract

Report
14/09/2005 | Marjorie Jouen | Catherine Palpant |
Social Europe in the throes of enlargement

Policy Paper
20/06/2005 | Marjorie Jouen | Catherine Palpant |
European social dialogue

Other document
04/05/2005 | Jacques Delors |
MÉDIAS
MEDIAS
Commission européenne : la Roumaine Roxana Minzatu, poids léger du social

Interview
20/10/2024 | Sofia Fernandes |
Quelle ambition sociale pour la nouvelle Commission européenne ?

Tribune
24/09/2024 | Sofia Fernandes |
En Europe, le grand chamboulement du marché du travail

Interview
04/05/2024 | Philippe Pochet |