Brief
The budgetary cost of solidarity in the euro zone: getting things clear and into perspective
In the face of the sovereign debt crisis, the Eurozone countries have put on a show of solidarity towards the countries in difficulty. This has triggered a lively debate on the costs of solidarity exercised within the Eurozone. This Policy Brief by Sofia Fernandes and Eulalia Rubio aims to clarify some points concerning the nature of the aid provided as well as its implications for national public finances.
The negotiations of the bailout plans for Greece, Ireland and Portugal as well as the adoption of new solidarity mechanisms have triggered a lively debate on the cost of these solidarity actions, particularly in those countries that are making the biggest contribution to those efforts such as Germany, The Netherlands, Finland and France.
This Policy Brief by Sofia Fernandes and Eulalia Rubio aims to clarify some points concerning the cost of interstate solidarity exercised within the Eurozone. The analysis focuses on the budgetary cost of that solidarity, which has been at the heart of this debate. It first clarifies the nature of these solidarity actions as well as their impact on national public finances. Then it analyses the current controversy over the budgetary implications of the growing imbalances in TARGET2 positions (the payment and settlement system between the central banks in the Eurozone) and, more generally, of the exceptional actions undertaken by the European Central Bank (ECB). Lastly, in order to give an order of magnitude of this solidarity effort, the Policy Brief places the total cost of interstate solidarity efforts in perspective by comparing it to the amount of money set aside by the states to help their banks since the start of the crisis.
SUR LE MÊME THÈME
ON THE SAME THEME
PUBLICATIONS
The war in Ukraine:
what are the consequences for European organisations?

Welcoming Ukrainian refugees in the EU

After Brexit, euro-denominated derivatives transactions should leave the City

MÉDIAS
MEDIAS
Marine Le Pen might be about to wreck the eurozone

War in Ukraine Bolstered EU Solidarity—Will it Last?

L’Irlandais Paschal Donohoe reconduit à la présidence de l’Eurogroupe

La solidarité financière, solution fragile de l’UE à la flambée de l’énergie

L’Unione europea si salva solo se ripartiamo dalla solidarietà tra gli Stati

Crise de l’énergie : la solidarité européenne passera-t-elle l’automne ?

Energie : un échange gagnant-gagnant entre la France et l’Allemagne ?

L’Union européenne va tenter de diminuer sa consommation de gaz, mais est-ce vraiment possible ?

EU solidarity frays as some member states question plan to slash gas use

EU solidarity frays as nations question plan to slash gas use

Défi énergétique, le choix de la sobriété

Face à la perspective d’un hiver sans gaz russe, les États européens appelés à la solidarité

Il y a vingt ans, l’arrivée des premiers euros

« L’hétérogénéité croissante de la zone euro menace sa cohésion »

Pourquoi la sortie de l’euro n’est plus un slogan politique

Andreas Eisl: «Les euros ont permis de comparer les pouvoirs d’achat»

Two decades on, euro can’t shake reputation as price driver

L’impression tenace de s’être fait berner sur les prix avec l’euro

L’actualité littéraire – Souveraineté et solidarité, un défi européen

L’euro, une construction encore inachevée

L’euro, une construction encore inachevée

“El fondo de recuperación es una victoria”

“Si l’attachement des Français aux fondamentaux de l’Europe est toujours là, le soutien à l’appartenance à l’UE est de plus en plus critique”

Le déficit de solidarité en Europe peut conduire au repli nationaliste

“Les détails pratiques de la mise en œuvre des ‘coronabonds’ seront plus importants que l’instrument choisi”

“Mon rêve c’est que l’Europe devienne leader sur les grans sujets à venir”

“Tout ce qui a pu être fait en matière de coordination a été fait, tout ce qui est financement pas encore.”

“Un plan de relance est nécessaire pour tourner la page de cette 1e phase de réponse européenne”

“Do not underestimate growing euro-frustration” among Italians.

“The EU’s lack of preparations, its powerlessness, its timidity, are staggering”

Eurogroup meeting: economic sovereignty and defending the single market were the elements to build a rapprochement

Mario Monti and Pascal Lamy call for joint issuance of public debt at EU level

Eurogroupe: “on peu trouver un accord si on met les drapeau de guerre de côté”

“L’Italia questa volta si gioca l’osso del collo”

“Il va nous falloir un énorme bazooka financier”

“Italia y España no piden limosnas, sino una solución europea a esta crisis”

“le Conseil européen a montré une nouvelle fois son caractère dysfonctionnel”

The Brussels Briefing of the Financial Times has taken a look at some of our ideas for the new European Commission

The Euro Area reform – Enrico Letta in El Diaro

The eurozone reform and what the EU can do better – E. Letta in The Federalist

A budget for the euro area ? – Eulalia Rubio in La Croix

Enrico Letta in BergamoNews about the euro crisis and the migratory phenomenon

Pascal Lamy in La Dépêche: “Il faut intégrer davantage la zone euro”

Jacques Delors in L’OBS: “Construire une Europe juste, durable, démocratique et inclusive”

Yves Bertoncini on France Info: Où en est vraiment l’europhophie en Allemagne, PaysBas et Hongrie ?

Enrico Letta on Public Sénat : Euro, terrorism, migrants, Brexit

Our report “Repair and prepare: growth and the euro after Brexit” in Géopolis

Our report “Repair and prepare: growth and the euro after Brexit” in Financial Times

Pascal Lamy on Le Parisien Magazine: “Faut-il sauver la peau de l’euro ?”

Our report “Repair and prepare: growth and the euro after Brexit” in Il Sole 24 Ore

Our report “Repair and prepare: growth and the euro after Brexit” in Les Echos

Our report “Repair and prepare: growth and the euro after Brexit” in Deutsche Welle

Our report “Repair and prepare: growth and the euro after Brexit” in Reuters

Antonio Vitorino on Observador : Socialistas em busca de nova “arma secreta” para o combate à desigualdade
