Policy paper
The EU ETS: from cornerstone to catalyst
THE ROLE OF CARBON PRICING IN DRIVING GREEN INNOVATION
By Johanna Lehne, Senior researcher, & Eleonora Moro, Researcher, at E3G, and Phuc-Vinh Nguyen, Researcher, & Thomas Pellerin-Carlin, Director, at the Energy Centre of the Jacques Delors Institute.
The European Commission has for a long time presented the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) as the cornerstone of EU climate policy, the policy that was, in theory, going to deliver emissions reductions in a dynamic, flexible, efficient way and incentivise clean innovation by shifting market dynamics.
Over time, as the ETS evolved, the politics surrounding EU climate policy, including a change in how stakeholders view the rate and the pace of change required, have shifted.
It is now clear that the ETS has driven certain kinds of clean innovation investments: incremental innovations that are already close to the market. It has accelerated the phaseout of some outdated technologies in the power sector, speeding-up a shift that was primarily kicked off by other instruments (direct investment support for renewables and complementary regulation). Yet, the ETS has so far largely failed to incentivise the development of solutions to reduce emissions in the energy-intensive industry sectors.
This paper explores the relationship between carbon pricing and innovation, setting out the key theoretical dynamics and elaborating on how these have played out in practice in the EU ETS. It concludes that, while the ETS cannot be the cornerstone of EU climate policy, it can be reformed to act as a powerful catalyst to accelerate the clean energy innovations needed to help the EU reach climate neutrality by 2050. This paper therefore ends with a set of recommendations in the context of the upcoming ETS revision:
- Strengthen the carbon price to foster close-to-market innovation
- Reduce price volatility by implementing an EU-wide carbon floor price that gradually increases over time
- Phase-out free allocations of ETS allowances by 2025 while preventing the occurrence of carbon leakage
- Increase the share of revenues from auctioning of ETS allowances dedicated to research & innovation
- Combine the ETS with ambitious regulatory policies to help pull through climate-neutral innovations
SUR LE MÊME THÈME
ON THE SAME THEME
PUBLICATIONS
Overview of the European electricity market

Make the Social Climate Fund a game changer to tackle energy poverty

The Swedish energy transition.
A race far from won

[FR] France’s energy future

Can a minimum price on carbon accelerate the adoption of clean technologies?

The need for a socially-just European Green Deal

United in diversity? National responses to the European energy crisis

Regional perspectives on energy citizenship and citizen participation in the energy transition

Energy Sufficiency

Stop feeding the bear

What do we mean when we talk about energy citizenship?

[EN] Setting the scene for a critical exploration of the roles of citizens in the European energy transition

European Dependence on Russian Gas
–The Example of Nord Stream 2

Climate policy
of the new German Government

No more free lunch. Ending free allowances in the EU ETS to the benefit of innovation

The European recovery plan as a breakthrough for green innovation? Challenges and opportunities for an innovative green recovery

TOWARDS A EUROPEAN HEALTH UNION

The German Energy transition

High energy prices. Russia fights back?

Addressing the climate and social emergencies with minimum energy performance standards

Cop 26: Europe leads the way towards climate neutrality

The European energy price spike

A Social Climate Fund for a fair energy transition

What are the ambitions of the German Green party

Putting the cart before the horse? PERSPECTIVES ON A POTENTIAL ETS ON RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS

Climate: How do MEPs vote?

the French and the environment

Make transatlantic cooperation great again

Let’s innovate to achieve climate neutrality

Make regulation fit for innovation

CHALLENGES FOR EUROPEAN RAIL

Europe needs to innovate
to become a front-runner in the global green economy race

Europe needs a political strategy to end energy poverty

How to lift 30 million Europeans out of Energy poverty?

5 years after the Paris Agreement, the largest global economies are engaging in the race towards climate neutrality

Making transatlantic relations green: a common agenda for climate action

Greening EU Trade 4:
How to “green” trade agreements?

European Green Transparency
Lessons from France and Further Room Improvement

Science and Innovation as the way out of the crisis

Europe continues its climate marathon

Joining forces to ensure a green and social recovery

Building a clean mobility system in times of COVID-19

A European Border Carbon Adjustment proposal
Greening EU trade – 3

Greener after

L’Europe sans charbon

Overcoming covid-19 crises
by building a clean and resilient Europe

Making the Green Deal a European success
Coalition, narrative, flagships

What business can do for the European Green Deal

What is the scope of the EU external Competence
in the field of energy today?

Russian gas pipelines and the EU: moving from a love-hate relationship “with adults in the room”?

To help fight climate change, we support increasing the Horizon Europe research and innovation budget

Cities in Europe
What EU innovation can do for climate neutrality

The European Green deal starts with the energy transition

Innovation for the energy & climate transition

A small electric car is 3 times cleaner than a small gasoline car

L’Europe de l’énergie existe : le citoyen l’a rencontrée

Climate Change: at the Heart of a New European Political Balance

Just energy transition: a reality test in Europe’s coal regions

Relever le défi énergétique et climatique en Europe : les propositions de 5 think tanks

Electric vehicles, european mobility and industrial leadership at stake

The Challenges of Chinese Investment Control in Europe

Clean Mobility: The European Way – A Comprehensive Approach to Electric Vehicles in the Energy Transition

InvestEU Fund: A Rebranded Juncker Fund?

Making better use of public funding: The role of national promotional banks and institutions in the next EU budget

MÉDIAS
MEDIAS
Les zones à faibles émissions, une stratégie pas si écologique

Le b.a.-ba des zones à faibles émissions avec Reporterre

En 2022, l’éolien et le solaire ont produit plus d’électricité que le gaz ou que le charbon au sein de l’Union européenne
