Policy paper 200
Are the spending priorities of euro-area countries converging?
Government expenditure accounts for between 30 and 60% of GDP in the euro area. Which countries spend the most? To what extent do countries differ in their spending priorities? Has there been any convergence since the inception of the EU’s monetary union?
Government expenditure accounts for between 30 and 60% of GDP in the euro area. Which countries spend the most? To what extent do countries differ in their spending priorities? Has there been any convergence since the inception of the EU’s monetary union?
In this Policy Paper, Jörg Haas, Research Fellow at the Jacques Delors Institut – Berlin and Robin Huguenot-Noël, Policy Analyst at the European Policy Centre (EPC) and Affiliate Fellow at Jacques Delors Institut – Berlin, analyse data on general government spending in the euro area and present it in seven charts. Their findings can be summarised as follows:
- Public spending ratios in the euro area vary widely and have shown no sign of lasting convergence since the inception of EMU. Belgium, Finland and France are countries with especially large public sectors, while the opposite applies to Ireland and the Baltics.
- The differences are especially pronounced when it comes to social protection. Large economies like France, Italy and Spain have seen relative spending levels increase in the last fifteen years, while they have fallen in Germany.
- When it comes to potentially growth-enhancing expenditure on education, public investment, and R&D, no uniform trend is discernible. However, several countries that were hit hard by the European debt crisis have decreased their productive spending.
- Generally, spending levels and priorities seem to reflect first and foremost domestic preferences and path dependency.
SUR LE MÊME THÈME
ON THE SAME THEME
PUBLICATIONS
The war in Ukraine:
what are the consequences for European organisations?

After Brexit, euro-denominated derivatives transactions should leave the City

From words to action

The Euro as seen by citizens who do not yet have it

The budgetary stick to the rescue of the rule of law?

A historic agreement, to be improved and implemented

An ambitious recovery budget, tough negotiations ahead

The EU budget and COVID: We need a “plan B”

Covid-19 and the Mobilisation of Public Development Banks in the EU

Tackling the coronavirus crisis:
how can the EU budget help?

Fiscal policy-making in the time of Coronavirus

Coronavirus
krach financier et krach politique

Corona: A European Safety Net for the Fiscal Response

The Member State compartment of the InvestEU Fund:
how does it work? Will it fly?

MFF negotiations: towards the end?

‘No deal’ Brexit and the EU budget:
beware the risk for EU unity

An EU budget in support of the next commission’s agenda

Innovation for the energy & climate transition

European Budget 2021-2027: how to escape from “business as usual”?

Budget européen, retrouver le sens du long terme

Negotiating the next Multi-Annual Financial Framework in an electoral year: which consequences?

InvestEU Fund: A Rebranded Juncker Fund?

The future of the Eurozone: cross-perspective from France and Germany

Making better use of public funding: The role of national promotional banks and institutions in the next EU budget

Why Meseberg matters – A short explainer

Merkel on EU reform: a decryption

No Escape from Politics: four tests for a successful fiscal instrument in the Euro area

Reinforcing the EU Budget with a fossil-fuel contribution

The Next Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF) and its Flexibility

Sovereign Debt: Do We Need an EU Solution?

Leaving the Euro: An Emergency Exit for the Currency Union?

EU budget: What’s the Cost of Europe?

Imbalances: Should the EU Intervene?

Economic Government: What Kind of Coordination for the Eurozone?

Understanding the “Brexit Divorce Bill”

The possible impact of Brexit on the EU budget and CAP funding

Juncker’s Last Hurrah

The EU as a 3-D Power: Should Europe Spend More on Diplomacy, Development and Defence?

The future of the European budget: What does the Commission’s White Paper mean for EU finances?

Making the Energy Transition a European Success

Extending Erasmus: a new impetus for youth mobility in Europe

Seizing the Moment for Euro Area Reform

The Awakening

A Euro for Growth and Convergence

How to prioritize structural reforms in the euro area?

Brexit and the EU budget: threat or opportunity?

Financial market fragmentation in the euro area: state of play

Does the Eurozone need a Parliament?

Public Sector Reform: How the EU budget is used to encourage it

Automatic stabilizers for the Euro area and the European social model

Repair and Prepare: Growth and the Euro after Brexit

National parliaments, surveillance mechanisms and ownership in the euro area

Automatic stabilisers for the euro area: what is on the table?

Why the Eurozone can’t agree on convergence. And how structural reforms can help

Investment in Europe: Making the best of the Juncker Plan

Labour mobility in the euro area: cure or curse?

Is there an alternative to the European economic policy? The European Parliament response

Federalising the Eurozone: Towards a true European budget?

What would a European finance minister do? A proposal

Sharing solidarity and sovereignty better: transcending “euroscoliosis”

After the Greek psychodrama, what improvements for the EMU?

After the Greek deal: why it is urgent to complete EMU

The EU and Greece: exiting “IMF – Europe” rather than the Euro

On asylum and the euro: displaying solidarity is in our own interest

Improving EMU: Our recommendations for the debate on the five presidents report

Grexit? Beware of slippery slopes

Repair and prepare: Strengthening Europe’s economies after the crisis

A new road map for the EU

The adjustements to the EU budget

What political and institutional evolutions for the EU and the EMU?

National budgets and European surveillance: Shedding light on the debate

Promoting structural reforms in the euro area: what for and how?

20 years “core Europe”

Reforming Europe’s governance

What the French told us about euro

What European democracy in the face of globalisation and the crisis?

Adjustment programmes in the euro area: mission accomplished?

Who calls the shots in the euro area? “Brussels” or the member states?

25 years after the Delors Report: what lessons for economic and monetary union?

The “stupidity pact” is not stable

The unhappy state of the Union

Inventing the European policies of tomorrow

Completing the Economic and Monetary Union

Which financial instrument to facilitate structural reforms in the euro area?

Towards a Euro Union

Blueprint for a Cyclical Shock Insurance in the euro area

The way out of the Cyprus economic crisis

Non-Community European spending

Beyond the Troika: which divides and faces for the EU?

Eurozone and democracy(ies) : a misleading debate

The Baltic states in the EU: yesterday, today and tomorrow

Rethinking the EMU and making Greater Europe positive again

Rebuilding Greater Europe

EU budget: the path to an agreement

The role and place of Parliaments in a genuine Economic and Monetary Union

The parliaments of the EU and the governance of the EMU

EU and growth: three pacts rather than one

National parliaments: their emerging control over the European Council

EU no, euro yes? European public opinions facing the crisis (2007-2012)

For a genuine EMU. Lessons from the international experience

European budget 2014-2020: seven years of bad luck?

Towards a common external representation for the eurozone ?

Is the stupidity pact still stable?

The EU and Turkey in the Southern Neighbourhood: a new opening?

How to maintain hard capabilities in times of budget cuts?

The EU budget: taking a second look

What political union for Europe?

Making one size fit all. Designing a cyclical adjustment insurance fund for the eurozone

Reflections on Political Union

The Nobel Prize, then what?

What balance between austerity and growth in the euro zone?

Reform proposals for the euro zone

A new path for growth and solidarity

Consolidating the EMU, a vital task

Britain and Europe – The last rites?

The euro zone, core of a political union

Spending better together: analyses and recommendations

Reforming the EU budget in times of crisis

Eurozone budget: 3 functions, 3 instruments
