Policy paper 202
France and Germany: Spearheading a European Security and Defence Union?
Despite a joint vision of France and Germany on a European Security and Defence Union, only cautious steps have been taken so far. This paper advocates incremental steps towards a more ambitious European Security and Defence Union.
The Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP) has become one of the most dynamic fields of European integration. The destabilisation of the EU’s neighbourhood, Brexit, and uncertainty in the transatlantic security partnership were important drivers behind this revitalisation. France and Germany reacted by jointly propagating the vision of a European Security and Defence Union. However, the CSDP is a policy area that has often been characterised by a gap between vision and action.
This paper, by Nicole Koenig, Senior research fellow at the Jacques Delors Institut – Berlin, and Marie Walter-Franke, Research associate at the Jacques Delors Institut – Berlin, offers a cautious assessment of the current window of opportunity, based on two questions:
This paper, by Nicole Koenig, Senior research fellow at the Jacques Delors Institut – Berlin, and Marie Walter-Franke, Research associate at the Jacques Delors Institut – Berlin, offers a cautious assessment of the current window of opportunity, based on two questions:
- First, is the necessary condition for deeper defence integration, a unified Franco-German leadership, really met?
- Second, is it a sufficient condition for the development of an ambitious Security and Defence Union?
The review of new drivers and old constraints offers a mixed picture. Despite a degree of strategic convergence between France and Germany, long-standing differences in terms of political culture and public perception persist. Not all EU member states are keen to follow the Franco-German lead. This mixed assessment explains why the EU has so far only taken cautious steps towards a European Security and Defence Union.
In light of the mix between drivers and constraints, this paper advocates incremental steps towards a
more ambitious European Security and Defence Union.
In light of the mix between drivers and constraints, this paper advocates incremental steps towards a
more ambitious European Security and Defence Union.
SUR LE MÊME THÈME
ON THE SAME THEME
PUBLICATIONS
War in Ukraine: a transformational impact on the European defence industry

Blog post
15/05/2025 | Bertrand de Cordoue |
White Paper: what prospects for a European armament policy?

Blog post
28/03/2025 | Bertrand de Cordoue |
Towards an EU–Ukraine alliance: A plan for an EU–Ukraine Joint Training Mission

Brief
27/03/2025 | Pierre Haroche |
The EU could and should put an end to unanimity when it comes to sanctions

Blog post
27/03/2025 | Guillaume Duval |
Europe’s “rearmament” and the programmed obsolescence of its fiscal framework

Brief
12/03/2025 | Pierre Jaillet |
Decompartmentalising national armament policies through ReArm EU

Blog post
11/03/2025 | Bertrand de Cordoue |
War mongers and peace makers

Blog post
10/03/2025 | Cyrille Bret |
Europe at the foot of the walls

Blog post
25/02/2025 | Nicole Gnesotto |
A White Paper on the future of European defence: what for?

Blog post
18/02/2025 | Bertrand de Cordoue |
For a Europeanisation of the sinews of war

Blog post
29/01/2025 | Bertrand de Cordoue |
Defence 25: thinking outside the box

Policy Paper
21/01/2025 | Nicole Gnesotto |
The European pillar of NATO

Other document
14/01/2025 | Thierry Tardy |
The European Union and the defence industry

Infographic
12/12/2024 | Bertrand de Cordoue |
Sovereignty, did you say sovereignty?

Blog post
03/12/2024 | Bertrand de Cordoue |
Securing the Baltic

Brief
08/11/2024 | Cyrille Bret |
A Rampart of Drones to Defend Europe

Brief
30/09/2024 | Pierre Haroche |
Turbo-charging the EU’s defence industry and security posture

Blog post
16/04/2024 | Thierry Tardy |
Promoting peace is not the same as fighting war

Blog post
06/12/2023 | Sylvie Matelly |
European defence Part 2 : Industries

Infographic
30/11/2023 | Sylvie Matelly | Thierry Tardy |
Arsenal Europe, Financing Military Capabilities for Ukraine and EU Member States

Brief
15/11/2023 | Pierre Haroche |
European defence Part 1 : budgets

Infographic
26/10/2023 | Thierry Tardy | Sylvie Matelly |
[FR] Faced with the Russian threat, which budgets for which defence?

Blog post
28/06/2023 | Thierry Tardy |
A new world order?

Blog post
13/03/2023 | Nicole Gnesotto |
What security guarantees can the EU provide to Ukraine?

Blog post
03/03/2023 | Pierre Haroche |
Victory, but what kind?

Blog post
01/03/2023 | Nicole Gnesotto |
Whose leadership will emerge from the new European geopolitical situation?

Blog post
22/02/2023 | Nicole Gnesotto |
Newletter february 2023

Blog post
01/02/2023 | Sébastien Maillard |
Germany — France
Differences and similarities

Infographic
18/01/2023 | Sacha Courtial |
[FR] Moteur d’un changement d’époque ? La France et l’Allemagne dans une Europe en mutation

Blog post
26/09/2022 | Eulalia Rubio |
Cyberattacks in Russia’s hybrid war against Ukraine

Policy Paper
21/09/2022 | Arnault Barichella |
Which European defence policy?

Infographic
01/09/2022 | Benjamin Couteau |
Strategic Compass: industry or power?

Blog post
04/04/2022 | Nicole Gnesotto |
European cybersecurity and data privacy:
Threats and prospects

Blog post
02/03/2022 | Arnault Barichella |
Le covid-19 remet-il en cause l’Europe de la défense ?

Blog post
18/05/2020 | Nicole Gnesotto |
L’armée européenne, y penser ?

Blog post
02/12/2019 |
Les Ateliers de la Citadelle

Blog post
04/02/2019 |
Aachen Treaty: A Second Look

Brief
Brexit: potential scenarios amid turbulent waters

Brief
25/07/2018 | Elvire Fabry | Nicole Koenig |
The future of the Eurozone: cross-perspective from France and Germany

Brief
25/07/2018 | Eulalia Rubio | Lucas Guttenberg |
The EU’s Four Strategic Challenges

Brief
10/07/2018 | Nicole Gnesotto |
Why Meseberg matters – A short explainer

Brief
22/06/2018 | Henrik Enderlein | Lucas Guttenberg |
Now or Never

Blog post
20/06/2018 | Enrico Letta |
A European Defence Union: In the name of the people?

Policy Paper
14/12/2017 | Nicole Koenig |
European Integration via Flexibility Tools: The Cases of EPPO and PESCO

Policy Paper
29/11/2017 | Valentin Kreilinger | Laura Maria Wolfstädter |
Strengthening European Defence: who sits at the PESCO table, what’s on the menu?

Brief
The EU as a 3-D Power: Should Europe Spend More on Diplomacy, Development and Defence?

Policy Paper
18/09/2017 | Nicole Koenig | Jörg Haas |
Brexit and the Area of Freedom, Security and Justice

Policy Paper
13/09/2017 | Funda Tekin |
Europe, Germany, France: Evolution of Public Opinions

Other document
Europe Facing the Challenge of Its Defence: Between Realism and Responsibility

Other document
03/07/2017 | Luc Vincent |
Enrico Letta about the main issues of the June 2017 EU Council

Other document
22/06/2017 | Enrico Letta |
#DigitalAmitié: a Franco-German Axis to Drive Digital Growth and Integration

Policy Paper
The Awakening

Other document
“Europeans’ fate is in their hands”

Other document
15/12/2016 | Enrico Letta |
Strengthening European collective security

Other document
14/12/2016 | Thomas Pellerin-Carlin |
France and Germany in the refugee crisis: united in diversity?

Other document
17/11/2016 | Nicole Koenig |
For an ambitious Europe

Other document
08/11/2016 | Jean-Claude Juncker |
Building the future of the EU: our generation’s duty

Other document
07/11/2016 | Manuel Valls |
The struggle against islamist terrorism: Franco-German and European responses

Other document
27/10/2016 | Yves Bertoncini |
Europe must rise to the challenges

Other document
17/03/2016 | Laurent Cohen-Tanugi | Daniel Cohn-Bendit | Henrik Enderlein | Hervé Gaymard | Sylvie Goulard | Elisabeth Guigou | Anne-Marie Le Gloannec | Thomas Oppermann | Norbert Röttgen |
What European security and defence policy do we need?

Other document
22/12/2015 | Elvire Fabry | Thomas Pellerin-Carlin |
European Defence Cooperation : speak the truth, act now

Other document
10/11/2015 | Thomas Pellerin-Carlin |
On asylum and the euro: displaying solidarity is in our own interest

Other document
23/06/2015 | António Vitorino |
Strengthening the European electricity market through improved Franco-German cooperation

Policy Paper
16/03/2015 | Stefan Bössner |
“Schengen”, terrorism and security

Other document
12/02/2015 | Yves Bertoncini | António Vitorino |
Resetting EU external action: potential and constraints

Policy Paper
03/02/2015 | Nicole Koenig |
Defence without Europe?

Other document
03/11/2014 |
Defenceless Europe?

Other document
03/11/2014 | Elvire Fabry | Jordan Rowell |
Why we should believe in European defence

Other document
03/11/2014 | Elisabeth Guigou |
20 years “core Europe”

Other document
30/09/2014 | Nicole Koenig |
Should European defence be scrapped?

Other document
11/09/2014 | Nicole Gnesotto |
European security after Libya and Ukraine: in search of a core leadership

Other document
Engaging Europe in the world

Other document
18/06/2014 | Jacques Delors | Pascal Lamy | António Vitorino | Eneko Landaburu | Elisabeth Guigou | Etienne Davignon | Nicole Gnesotto | Philippe De Schoutheete | Elvire Fabry | Sami Andoura |
Europeans and the use of force

Brief
16/12/2013 | António Vitorino | Elvire Fabry |
Foreign Policy and External Actions : an “unsurpassable horizon” for the EU?

Other document
05/11/2013 | Yves Bertoncini |
Think Global – Act European IV. Thinking Strategically about the EU’s External Action

Report
16/10/2013 | Elvire Fabry |
Rebuilding Greater Europe

Other document
19/06/2013 | Jacques Delors |
Europe of Defence: A pragmatic approach

Other document
28/05/2013 | Jean-Yves Le Drian |
Think Global – Act European IV – Thinking Strategically about the EU’s External Action

Report
30/04/2013 | Elvire Fabry | Chiara Rosselli |
Defence: The French ambition for Europe

Other document
29/04/2013 | Sophie-Caroline De Margerie | Nicole Gnesotto |
European budget 2014-2020: seven years of bad luck?

Other document
18/03/2013 | Nadège Chambon | Marie Billotte |
Will Europeans ever agree on the use of military force?

Policy Paper
13/02/2013 | Jan Techau |
How to maintain hard capabilities in times of budget cuts?

Policy Paper
13/02/2013 | Ronja Kempin |
Strategic Priorities for EU Defence Policy

Policy Paper
13/02/2013 | Daniel Keohane |
The European Defence Industry’s Future: How European?

Policy Paper
13/02/2013 |
Enough Sauerkraut and Beer

Other document
22/01/2013 | Jacques Delors |
Germany, France, EU: acting together

Other document
Welfare state sustainability: resetting EU migration strategy?

Other document
07/01/2013 | Chiara Rosselli | Elvire Fabry |
EU defence capacities: maintaining credibility?

Other document
11/12/2012 | Elvire Fabry | Chiara Rosselli |
Europe abroad : twenty years after Maastricht, is there anybody there ?

Other document
27/03/2012 | Sami Andoura |
Defence spending in Europe: Can we do better without spending more?

Policy Paper
29/06/2011 | Fabio Liberti |
Kosovo after 10 December 2007: What’s at stake for the European Union

Other document
07/12/2007 | Tamara Buschek | Bertrand de Largentaye |
Towards a new social contract in Europe. France-Germany economic changes and social models

Other document
20/05/2007 |
Considerations on the Iraq Crise and the Effects on the Foreign Policy Common to the day before of an announced War

Other document
03/01/2007 | Bertrand de Largentaye |
A driving force despite everything, Franco-German relations and the Enlarged European Union

Report
22/08/2006 | Martin Koopmann |
The world is the stage: a global security strategy for the European Union

Policy Paper
22/08/2006 | Sven Biscop | Rik Coolsaet |
A View from Outside: the Franco-German couple as seen by their partners

Report
The New Institutional Architecture of the European Union: a Franco-German third Way?

Report
The Franco-German motor facing Agenda 2000

Other document
22/08/2006 | Jacques Delors |
Europe and Franco-German relationship

Other document
22/08/2006 |
Saint Malo plus five: an interim assessment of ESDP

Policy Paper
30/11/2003 | Jolyon Howorth |
9/11 and the Europeanisation of anti-terrorism policy: a critical assessment

Blog post
24/09/2003 | Monica Den Boer |
The European Security Conundrum: Prospects for ESDP after September 11, 2001

Policy Paper
28/02/2002 | Jolyon Howorth |
MÉDIAS
MEDIAS
« Pologne, la puissance européenne de 2025 ? »

Interview
21/01/2025 | Cyrille Bret |
Nicole Gnesotto, historienne : « D’un pacifisme structurel, l’Europe doit passer à un réarmement solide »

Interview
16/12/2024 | Nicole Gnesotto |
L’OTAN demande aux entreprises européennes de se préparer à un “scénario de guerre” : concrètement, de quoi la France est-elle capable ?

Interview
27/11/2024 | Sylvie Matelly |