Policy Paper
How to Explain the Unexpected: An Assessment of the French Constitutional Referendum
Many paradoxes underscore the need to analyse the ongoing French debate and to advance a few explanatory factors. Hence, this policy paper by Gaetane Ricard-Nihoul and Morgan Lahrant has three distinct parts. The first provides a general description of the main events since mid-July, the second describes the most relevant actors in the campaign and, finally, the third attempts to put forward some explanations.
When the French referendum on the European Constitution is considered from abroad it appears to be full of paradoxes.
First, although the major political parties have officially endorsed the text, there is still an enormous uncertainty as to the outcome. All the polls since mid-march have indeed placed the “no” side in a leading position. Secondly, although only the first two parts of the text present new elements, the debate has so far centered on the third part. Some of the basic principles of the Rome Treaty of 1957, such as free competition and the four freedoms of movement now appear excessively liberal to be “engraved” in a constitution.
Thirdly, despite the intensity of the debate the campaign has mainly focused on issues that are unrelated to the Constitution (for instance, the Bolkestein directive and Turkish membership of the EU).
These paradoxes underscore the need to analyze the ongoing French debate and to advance a few explanatory factors. Hence, this paper has three distinct parts. The first provides a general description of the main events since mid-July, the second describes the most relevant actors in the campaign and, finally, the third attempts to put forward some explanations
SUR LE MÊME THÈME
ON THE SAME THEME
PUBLICATIONS
The Resilience of Critical Raw Materials Value Chains in France
Policy Paper
11/10/2024 | Thibaud Voïta |
Sufficiency, the year after
Brief
02/09/2024 | Phuc-Vinh Nguyen | Fiona Breucker |
A democracy under severe strain…
Blog post
10/07/2024 | Sylvie Matelly |
Green Deal: towards a “European regulatory pause”?
Brief
09/01/2024 | Phuc-Vinh Nguyen |
United in diversity? National responses to the European energy crisis
Other document
FRENCH-STYLE EUROSCEPTICISM
Report
Teaching Europe in France
Blog post
08/10/2020 | Thierry Chopin |
French public opinion and Europe
between distrust and ambivalence
Blog post
Now or Never
Blog post
20/06/2018 | Enrico Letta |
The European ambition of President Macron and the reactions in Europe to his project
Other document
01/06/2018 | Sébastien Maillard |
European Democracy: What Are the Next Challenges
Other document
04/07/2017 | Hamza Abbas |
French and Europeans: Stronger Together!
Other document
National Referendums on EU Issues: from Clarification to Frustration
Policy Paper
03/04/2017 | Yves Bertoncini |
Living Together Facing Fears: the French Political Dilemma
Policy Paper
16/03/2017 | Yves Bertoncini | Dídac Gutiérrez-Peris |
The EU and referenda: three denials of democracy
Other document
23/06/2016 | Yves Bertoncini |
The new French Regions, from a European standpoint
Policy Paper
01/12/2015 | Marjorie Jouen |
The EU and referenda: structural incompatibility?
Policy Paper
17/09/2015 | Yves Bertoncini | Nicole Koenig |
France: A hotbed of opposition to the TTIP?
Policy Paper
10/06/2015 | Elvire Fabry |
The EU and referenda on independence: a leap in the dark?
Other document
17/09/2014 | Yves Bertoncini |
European elections: What form of cohabitation between France and the EU?
Brief
26/05/2014 | Yves Bertoncini |
What the French told us about the employement in the EU
Other document
23/05/2014 | Nicolò Conti |
What the French told us about the European democracy
Other document
23/05/2014 | Nicolò Conti |
What the French told us about euro
Other document
23/05/2014 | Nicolò Conti |
What the French told us about globalisation
Other document
23/05/2014 | Nicolò Conti |
Defence: The French ambition for Europe
Other document
29/04/2013 | Sophie-Caroline De Margerie | Nicole Gnesotto |
France votes: Europe intrudes
Other document
23/03/2012 | Julian Priestley |
Francia: triste dilemma
Other document
23/03/2012 | Riccardo Perissich |
“Europe without barriers” and “Europe that protects”
Other document
19/12/2008 | Jacques Rupnik |
Think Global – Act European I (TGAE I). The contribution of 13 European Think Tanks to the French, Czech and Swedish EU Trio Presidency.
Report
03/10/2008 | Elvire Fabry |
What is the real room for manoeuvre of an EU Presidency ?
Brief
15/09/2008 |
The French Presidency of the EU Council: a big boat in stormy weather”
Other document
18/08/2008 | Gaëtane Ricard-Nihoul |
The French Presidency of the EU Council
Brief
04/07/2008 | Elvire Fabry | Gaëtane Ricard-Nihoul |
The Constitutional Treaty and the June Summit: A way forward?
Brief
07/06/2007 | Gaëtane Ricard-Nihoul |
Europe in the French Presidential Elections: Side Show, Fall Guy or Just Conspicuous by its Absence?
Policy Paper
17/04/2007 | Gaëtane Ricard-Nihoul |
Leading from behind: Britain and the European Constitutional Treaty
Report
26/02/2007 | Anand Menon | Jacques Delors |
Can Europe’s Foreign Policy rekindle the Constitutional Process?
Policy Paper
11/01/2007 | Gilles Andréani | Jean De Ruyt |
Constitutional referendum in France: a mid-term assessment
Other document
03/01/2007 | Morgan Larhant |
Letter to our European friends who want to Vote not
Other document
29/12/2006 | Jacques Delors |
Draft Constitution? Why a “rear guard” should be established
Other document
29/12/2006 | François Lamoureux |
Landscape after the battle
Other document
29/12/2006 | Jean Pisani-Ferry |
The European constitution – a step in before for the EU
Other document
27/12/2006 | Jacques Delors |
What can we learn from the Collapse of European Constitutional Project? A Response to Eight Critics
Other document
15/11/2006 | Andrew Moravcsik |
The Impact of the Television Media on the French Referendum Campaign in 2005
Report
31/10/2006 | Jacques Gerstlé |
Plan B: How to Rescue the European Constitution
Report
18/10/2006 | Andrew Duff |
Reaction of Jeremy A. Rabkin to Andrew Moravcsik’s article on the collapse of the Constitutional treaty
Other document
10/10/2006 | Jeremy A. Rabkin |
Reaction of Mark N. Franklin to Andrew Moravcsik’s article on the collapse of the Constitutional treaty
Other document
09/10/2006 | Mark N. Franklin |
Reaction of Giandomenico Majone to Andrew Moravcsik’s article on the collapse of the Constitutional treaty
Other document
05/10/2006 | Giandomenico Majone |
Reaction of Loukas Tsoukalis to Andrew Moravcsik’s article on the collapse of the Constitutional treaty
Other document
04/10/2006 | Loukas Tsoukalis |
Reaction of Pepper D. Culpepper and Archon Fung to Andrew Moravcsik’s article on the collapse of the Constitutional treaty
Other document
02/10/2006 | Archon Fung | Pepper Culpepper |
Reaction of Paul Magnette to Andrew Moravcsik’s article on the collapse of the Constitutional treaty
Other document
29/09/2006 | Paul Magnette |
Reaction of James Fishkin to Andrew Moravcsik’s article on the collapse of the Constitutional treaty
Other document
27/09/2006 | Francesco Marchi |
Can you imagine a referendum to European level and under what conditions?
Policy Paper
22/09/2006 | Yannis Papadopoulos |
Referenda in other countries: the case of Spain
Other document
22/08/2006 | Morgan Larhant |
The First Dutch Referendum: a pre-ballot assessment
Policy Paper
22/08/2006 | Arjen Nijeboer |
The Constitutional Treaty: What Now?
Other document
08/06/2006 | Gaëtane Ricard-Nihoul |
Democratising European Democracy
Policy Paper
29/11/2005 | Stephen Boucher |
The European Constitution and deliberation: the Example of deliberative focus groups ahead of the French Referendum of 29 May 2005
Report
29/11/2005 | Henri Monceau |
The French “no” vote of 29 May 2005: understand, act
Report
18/10/2005 | Gaëtane Ricard-Nihoul |
Securing a “Yes”: from Nice I to Nice II
Policy Paper
25/04/2005 | Adrian Langan | Brigid Laffan |
“The Constitution, a step forward for the European Union” intervention by Jacques Delors
Other document
13/04/2005 | Jacques Delors |
Ratification and Revision of the Consitutional Treaty
Report
13/04/2005 | Henri Oberdorff |
Adress to the Symposium of “Témoin” Club
Other document
25/11/2004 | Jacques Delors |
A new institutional equilibrium and collective sovereignty
Other document
24/08/2004 | Jacques Delors |
The European debate in France at the start of the French presidency
Report
30/06/2000 | Jean-Louis Arnaud | Jacques Delors |
MÉDIAS
MEDIAS
AUX ARMES, CITOYENS
Interview
06/12/2024 | Phuc-Vinh Nguyen |
French government collapses
Vidéo
06/12/2024 | Sébastien Maillard |
Accord du Mercosur: La France a-t-elle les moyens de l’empêcher?
Vidéo
06/12/2024 | Elvire Fabry |