Brief
The budgetary cost of solidarity in the euro zone: getting things clear and into perspective
In the face of the sovereign debt crisis, the Eurozone countries have put on a show of solidarity towards the countries in difficulty. This has triggered a lively debate on the costs of solidarity exercised within the Eurozone. This Policy Brief by Sofia Fernandes and Eulalia Rubio aims to clarify some points concerning the nature of the aid provided as well as its implications for national public finances.
The negotiations of the bailout plans for Greece, Ireland and Portugal as well as the adoption of new solidarity mechanisms have triggered a lively debate on the cost of these solidarity actions, particularly in those countries that are making the biggest contribution to those efforts such as Germany, The Netherlands, Finland and France.
This Policy Brief by Sofia Fernandes and Eulalia Rubio aims to clarify some points concerning the cost of interstate solidarity exercised within the Eurozone. The analysis focuses on the budgetary cost of that solidarity, which has been at the heart of this debate. It first clarifies the nature of these solidarity actions as well as their impact on national public finances. Then it analyses the current controversy over the budgetary implications of the growing imbalances in TARGET2 positions (the payment and settlement system between the central banks in the Eurozone) and, more generally, of the exceptional actions undertaken by the European Central Bank (ECB). Lastly, in order to give an order of magnitude of this solidarity effort, the Policy Brief places the total cost of interstate solidarity efforts in perspective by comparing it to the amount of money set aside by the states to help their banks since the start of the crisis.
SUR LE MÊME THÈME
ON THE SAME THEME
PUBLICATIONS
The war in Ukraine:
what are the consequences for European organisations?

Welcoming Ukrainian refugees in the EU

After Brexit, euro-denominated derivatives transactions should leave the City

Migration, asylum, mobility and integration in Europe: inseparable common values

The Euro as seen by citizens who do not yet have it

COVAX: Europe put to the test of global vaccine solidarity

SURE or the EU to aid European workers

Crisis notebook

SURE : A welcome LYNCHPIN for A European unemployment re-insurance

The EU facing the coronavirus:
A political urgency to embody European solidarity

Solidarity within the Eurozone :
how much, what for, for how long ?

Corona: A European Safety Net for the Fiscal Response

The future of the Eurozone: cross-perspective from France and Germany

Why Meseberg matters – A short explainer

Merkel on EU reform: a decryption

For a Regional Solidarity Policy After 2020

No Escape from Politics: four tests for a successful fiscal instrument in the Euro area

Leaving the Euro: An Emergency Exit for the Currency Union?

Imbalances: Should the EU Intervene?

Economic Government: What Kind of Coordination for the Eurozone?

Sovereign Debt: Do We Need an EU Solution?

Juncker’s Last Hurrah

Are the spending priorities of euro-area countries converging?

Solidarity 2.0

Seizing the Moment for Euro Area Reform

The Future Cohesion Policy Should Represent EU Solidarity in Action

The Awakening

A Euro for Growth and Convergence

How to prioritize structural reforms in the euro area?

Financial market fragmentation in the euro area: state of play

Does the Eurozone need a Parliament?

Automatic stabilizers for the Euro area and the European social model

Repair and Prepare: Growth and the Euro after Brexit

National parliaments, surveillance mechanisms and ownership in the euro area

Automatic stabilisers for the euro area: what is on the table?

Why the Eurozone can’t agree on convergence. And how structural reforms can help

What priorities for the cohesion policy after 2020?

Labour mobility in the euro area: cure or curse?

Federalising the Eurozone: Towards a true European budget?

Social inequalities in Europe: the challenge of convergence and cohesion

The new French Regions, from a European standpoint

What would a European finance minister do? A proposal

Sharing solidarity and sovereignty better: transcending “euroscoliosis”

After the Greek psychodrama, what improvements for the EMU?

After the Greek deal: why it is urgent to complete EMU

The EU and Greece: exiting “IMF – Europe” rather than the Euro

On asylum and the euro: displaying solidarity is in our own interest

Improving EMU: Our recommendations for the debate on the five presidents report

More European solidarity before migrant crises

Grexit? Beware of slippery slopes

Repair and prepare: Strengthening Europe’s economies after the crisis

A new road map for the EU

What political and institutional evolutions for the EU and the EMU?

National budgets and European surveillance: Shedding light on the debate

Promoting structural reforms in the euro area: what for and how?

20 years “core Europe”

Engaging Europe in the world

What the French told us about euro

What European democracy in the face of globalisation and the crisis?

Adjustment programmes in the euro area: mission accomplished?

25 years after the Delors Report: what lessons for economic and monetary union?

The “stupidity pact” is not stable

The unhappy state of the Union

Inventing the European policies of tomorrow

Completing the Economic and Monetary Union

Which financial instrument to facilitate structural reforms in the euro area?

Towards a Euro Union

Blueprint for a Cyclical Shock Insurance in the euro area

The way out of the Cyprus economic crisis

Energy solidarity in Europe: from independence to interdependence

Beyond the Troika: which divides and faces for the EU?

Eurozone and democracy(ies) : a misleading debate

The Baltic states in the EU: yesterday, today and tomorrow

Rethinking the EMU and making Greater Europe positive again

Rebuilding Greater Europe

The parliaments of the EU and the governance of the EMU

National parliaments: their emerging control over the European Council

EU no, euro yes? European public opinions facing the crisis (2007-2012)

For a genuine EMU. Lessons from the international experience

European budget 2014-2020: seven years of bad luck?

Towards a common external representation for the eurozone ?

Is the stupidity pact still stable?

The EU and Turkey in the Southern Neighbourhood: a new opening?

What political union for Europe?

Making one size fit all. Designing a cyclical adjustment insurance fund for the eurozone

Reflections on Political Union

The Nobel Prize, then what?

What balance between austerity and growth in the euro zone?

Reform proposals for the euro zone

A new path for growth and solidarity

Consolidating the EMU, a vital task

The euro zone, core of a political union

Eurozone budget: 3 functions, 3 instruments

Competition, Cooperation, Solidarity: new challenges

Jacques Delors’ “Triptych”: current situation and prospects

The interim report on the EMU is encouraging

Which Institutions for the Euro Area?

EMU: long-term matters are urgent matters

Fire-fighters, Policemen and Architects for European Integration

Setting up and governing the euro

Completing the Euro: A road map towards fiscal union in Europe

European guarantees to get out of the crisis?

Brussels, 2 May 2012 – What Are the Risks of Small Steps in a Rapidly Changing World?

Public Opinion and the Eurozone Crisis – PEW Global Attitudes Survey

“Europe’s high noon approaches”

For a revival of Europe

Pascal Lamy’ speech “Europe in the Global Economy”

The politics of the EMU governance

The ‘TSCG’: much ado about nothing?

Solidarity within the Eurozone: how much, what for, for how long?

The Future of Europe in the New Global Economy

A two-pronged defence of the Euro

Solidarity within the European Union: political foundations

The Demons Awake : The Euro Crisis and how to emerge from it

The euro and the crises

Subsidiarity versus Solidarity? The example of the European Food Aid Program for the Most Deprived

The euro, words and facts

“The euro, in historical and institutional terms”

Food program under discussion: the end of a European solidarity towards the most deprived persons?
