Policy Paper 64
Where does CSDP fit in EU foreign policy?
Nick Witney, Senior Policy Fellow, ECFR —
The Lisbon Treaty describes CSDP as ‘integral’ to Europe’s foreign policy. Yet European leaders’ actions belie any such belief. The EU has gone ‘missing in action’ in north Africa: ‘pooling and sharing’ is discussed but not practised. Governments aborted the EADS/BAES merger, for narrow national reasons.
This lack of seriousness about defence stems from intervention fatigue, and the absence of any direct military threat. But the hegemony of the West is finished; the US is pivoting to Asia; and Europe is being rapidly marginalised. It needs to exploit all its assets, including its armed forces, to continue to count in the world.
The missing understanding is how the military can be used as a tool of statecraft. Europe’s ability to offer assistance and training, intelligence and arms, should be a key conduit of influence – for example, with the new democracies of north Africa.
Europeans need to re-think the global strategic environment, and how their armed forces can support foreign policy. The European Council should commission a European Defence Review, to produce both a strategic re-assessment and proposals for major integrative projects.
The Lisbon Treaty describes CSDP as ‘integral’ to Europe’s foreign policy. Yet European leaders’ actions belie any such belief. The EU has gone ‘missing in action’ in north Africa: ‘pooling and sharing’ is discussed but not practised. Governments aborted the EADS/BAES merger, for narrow national reasons.
This lack of seriousness about defence stems from intervention fatigue, and the absence of any direct military threat. But the hegemony of the West is finished; the US is pivoting to Asia; and Europe is being rapidly marginalised. It needs to exploit all its assets, including its armed forces, to continue to count in the world.
The missing understanding is how the military can be used as a tool of statecraft. Europe’s ability to offer assistance and training, intelligence and arms, should be a key conduit of influence – for example, with the new democracies of north Africa.
Europeans need to re-think the global strategic environment, and how their armed forces can support foreign policy. The European Council should commission a European Defence Review, to produce both a strategic re-assessment and proposals for major integrative projects.
Before the publication of the final report presenting the key recommendations of the 16 think tanks involved in the project, 5 series of Policy Papers address the following key challenges: CSDP, EU neighbourhood, strategic resources, migration and economic policy.
The project is led with the support of the
SUR LE MÊME THÈME
ON THE SAME THEME
PUBLICATIONS
Taking the European Neighbourhood Policy beyond the conception-performance gap

The European neighbourhood and the EU’s security of supply with natural gas

Neighbourhood policy: more or no more?

MÉDIAS
MEDIAS
Ukraine, l’Europe unie dans son soutien

Vers une entrée rapide de l’Ukraine dans l’UE ? “Un symbole fort mais peu réaliste”

Macron à Moscou et Kiev : “La crise ukrainienne est une occasion à ne pas rater pour la France”

Crise ukrainienne : et si l’Occident paralysait les paiements de la Russie ?

Vous n’avez rien compris à ce qu’il se passe entre la Russie et l’Ukraine ? On vous explique

Crise ukrainienne : des Russes aux Occidentaux, qui fait quoi ?

Ukraine : l’Europe peut-elle être autre chose que spectatrice ?

Ukraine: «Après 1991, l’Occident n’a pas su aider la Russie»

« Il y a un fossé entre les interventions militaires de la Russie et la reconstruction de l’URSS »

« Les Occidentaux doivent réfléchir à une finlandisation de l’Ukraine »

Conflit Ukraine-Russie : Entre « dramatisation », « hystérie » et « attaque imminente », la guerre des mots continue

Russie-Otan: comment les relations se sont peu à peu envenimées

Snobés sur l’Ukraine, les Européens doivent-ils sanctionner le Kazakhstan?

Kazakhstan: «La hantise de la présidence Poutine, ce sont les révolutions de couleurs»

Vor USA-Russland-Verhandlungen: Josep Borrell zu Gesprächen in Ukraine

L’UE veut peser face aux Etats-Unis et à la Russie dans le dossier ukrainien

L’Union européenne envoie un signal de soutien aux pays de son voisinage oriental

Ukraine, Moldavie, Géorgie… Avec ses voisins de l’Est, l’UE tente de trouver une réponse à la Russie
